Stance: an international undergraduate philosophy journal
type: channel
description: Stance is an international undergraduate philosophy journal. It is produced and edited entirely by undergraduate students, and all original article are written by undergraduates. The aim of Stance is to enrich student learning by providing an opportunity for undergraduate students to have their original scholarly work reviewed by and possibly published in a peer-reviewed academic journal.
publisher: Ball State University
language: en-US
publication name: Stance: an international undergraduate philosophy journal
issn: 1943-1899
copyright: Stance requires right of first publication. All other rights reside with the author. Authors are free to reuse their own articles in other publications they write or edit, and no further permission is required. The journal only requires acknowledgement of the original publication in Stance. All articles are licensed with a Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial No-Derivatives 4.0 International license.
items: Examining Aristotle's Substance
items: Condemned to Break the Law
items: A History of Marxist Hegemony
items: Pastries to Die For
items: Goal Achievement in Classical Stoicism and Modern $toicism
items: Artistic Classism and "Camp" as Critical Kitsch
items: Explaining Mansplaing through Frameworks of Silencing, Epistemic Injustice, and Gender Metaphysics
items: Why Structuralism Fails in Interpreting Visual Art
items: Towards an Account of Complementarities and Context-Dependence
items: Do My Signals Deceive Me?
items: The Rending of the Veil: Tarrying with the Technological Sublime
items: Nietzsche and the Birth of Joker
items: The Relevance of Embodied Practice to Philosophical Understanding
items: More Than We Can Chew
items: The Formation of Body Memory Under Patriarchy
items: A Good Little Girl is One Who Grows Up to Be a Woman
items: A Phenomenological Approach to Legal Epistemic Injustice
items: In Defense of Immoralism
items: On the Essence of Thought Experiments
items: Science and the Question of Truth
items: Back End
items: Front End
items: Language, Feminism, and Racism
items: On the Governance of Women’s Rights in Taliban Afghanistan
items: The Rule of Law and Jury Trials
items: Escaping Self-Sacrifice
items: Autistic Students within the Community of Inquiry
items: Shapeshifting
items: Addressing Crimes of Passion with the Deep-Self View of Moral Responsibility
items: Sanjiao Heyi and Tibet
items: Music, Cage's Silence, and Art
items: Kantian Disregard for Non-Rational Humans
items: How a Buddha Acts
items: Putnam's Problem of the Robot and Extended Minds
items: Thinking and Speaking
items: Bringing the Marginalized into Epistemology
items: On the Structure of Consciousness
items: Is J.S. Mill's Account of Free Speech Sustainable in the Age of Social Media?
items: The Case Against Speciesism and Sexism
items: The Wisdom of Wizards
items: Why Does God Need Freedom?
items: Origin, Impact, and Reaction to Misogynistic Behaviors
items: Post-Hierarchical Race
items: Why the Readiness Potential Does Not Disprove Free Will
items: Avoiding the Swine
items: In Defense of Platonic Essentialism About Numbers
items: Hegel's Projected Nihilism
items: Clashing Consciousness
items: Being Moral Isn't Quite Enough
items: Full Blooded Conceptual Realism as a Response to Skeptical Relativism
items: Black Women in Fanon's Black Skin, White Masks
items: A Two-Part Defense of Intuitionistic Mathematics
items: The Plate is Political
items: Supporters
items: Philosophy as a Helping Profession
items: If There's No Music Up in Heaven Then What's it For?
items: Kripkenstein and Mathematics as the Language of Nature
items: A Step Toward the Elucidation of Quantitative Laws of Nature
items: Problems of Framing
items: We Don't Know We Have Hands and it's Fine
items: Fanon and Recognition
items: Let's Talk About the Birds, Not the Bees
items: Not So Skeptical
items: How to Scrutinize the Market God
items: A Philosophical Analysis of AI and Racism
items: A Proposal for a Coherentist-Constitutivist Account of Normativity
items: Love and Rationality
items: Cover

Examining Aristotle's Substance
type: item
description: When examining Aristotle’s works, it is difficult to properly explain his account of substance, and even more so to understand what things can be considered as natural substances. Typically, artifacts have been believed not to be natural substances, since they lack a certain autonomy living organisms have. However, this argument may not be fully adequate depending on how “artifact” and “organism” are understood. I argue that due to advances in the autonomy of Artificial Intelligence, a reinterpretation of the distinction between artifacts and natural substances could be warranted.
creator: Braden Cooper
rights: Copyright (c) 2025 Braden Cooper https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2025-04-14
publication date: 2025-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 10
ending page: 21
doi: 10.33043/83nWdN5n

Condemned to Break the Law
type: item
description: Homelessness is a widespread issue that impacts the lives of thousands and motivates the actions of various governmental entities. In “Condemned to Break the Law: The Legality and Fairness of Anti-Camping Laws in Response to the Homelessness Crisis,” I argue that governments have an obligation to make laws that can be reasonably followed. The analysis of obligation incorporates concepts of penological purpose and the capacity to follow the law. These philosophical measurements are applied to the Supreme Court’s decision to permit anti-camping laws in Grants Pass v. Johnson 603 US ___ (2024) to situate these concepts in a real-world context.
creator: Genevieve Morea
rights: Copyright (c) 2025 Genevieve Morea https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2025-04-14
publication date: 2025-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 114
ending page: 125
doi: 10.33043/vSWScnca

A History of Marxist Hegemony
type: item
description: Hegemony, as popularized by Antonio Gramsci, has earned great importance in Marxist debates over the conquest of power. Unsurprisingly, this has also led to a renewed exploration of its origins in the writings of Vladimir Lenin, Georgi Plekhanov, and even Karl Kautsky as argued by the historian Lars Lih. This paper examines that history by returning to their original writings and contemporary analysis by Grigory Zinoviev. In doing so, I demonstrate a fundamental break between the original "strategy" of hegemony found in earlier theorists and Lenin’s "theory" of hegemony as elaborated upon by Gramsci.
creator: Sylus Smith
rights: Copyright (c) 2025 Sylus Smith https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2025-04-14
publication date: 2025-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 100
ending page: 113
doi: 10.33043/YFyDh5BN

Pastries to Die For
type: item
description: An objection to ethical vegetarianism is that the consumption of meat does not causally influence the production of meat. The objection relies on a principle called the Causal Efficacy Principle. The principle states that if an action does not directly cause harm, then that action is morally permissible. I provide a thought experiment as a counterexample to this principle, and then, I attempt to diagnose why the principle is false in terms of moral cooperation. Moral cooperation is when many people perform an action that individually does not prevent harm, but prevents harm when the group all performs the action.
creator: Micah George
rights: Copyright (c) 2025 Micah George https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2025-04-14
publication date: 2025-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 126
ending page: 137
doi: 10.33043/pBGvBNk7

Goal Achievement in Classical Stoicism and Modern $toicism
type: item
description: Many claim the philosophy of Stoicism is useful for goal achievement, suggesting it is conducive to productivity and success. However, classical Stoicism is directly opposed to goal-achievement mentalities. While Stoicism focuses primarily on developing a certain standard of moral character regardless of external circumstances, this modern goal-orientation focuses exclusively on external achievements, most often toward financial ends. Thus, I distinguish the two as Stoicism in the former and $toicism in the latter. I discuss key differences in how the two views approach goal achievement, revealing that modern $toicism is not a revival but a misrepresentation of classical Stoicism.
creator: Nathan Phillips
rights: Copyright (c) 2025 Nathan Phillips https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2025-04-14
publication date: 2025-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 60
ending page: 73
doi: 10.33043/R6rZPcAb

Artistic Classism and "Camp" as Critical Kitsch
type: item
description: In the philosophy of art and art criticism, there is disagreement over whether works deemed “kitsch” can be considered art. I discuss the perspectives of two thinkers, Clement Greenberg and Robert Solomon, to elucidate the kitsch debate as ultimately an issue of classism. Using AP Nguyễn’s exhibition Lovecore as a case study, I consider how the artist utilizes the concept of “camp” to assert the value of kitsch and comment on the classism of art criticism that denigrates kitsch art. Camp as critical kitsch celebrates artworks for the same kitschy qualities that many critics cite as negating their ability to be called art at all.
creator: Cass Duxbury
rights: Copyright (c) 2025 Cass Duxbury https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2025-04-14
publication date: 2025-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 22
ending page: 31
doi: 10.33043/6nphspS3

Explaining Mansplaing through Frameworks of Silencing, Epistemic Injustice, and Gender Metaphysics
type: item
description: This paper argues that mansplaining is not just a conversational quirk but a mechanism of gender construction that reinforces systemic oppression. Drawing on the frameworks of silencing, epistemic injustice, and gender metaphysics, I come to the main thesis that mansplaining is one way gender is constructed, reinforcing hierarchical power structures and perpetuating societal inequality. As I further demonstrate, mansplaining functions as a form of epistemic violence that silences women and subordinates them within testimonial exchanges.
creator: Maria Jankowska
rights: Copyright (c) 2025 Maria Jankowska https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2025-04-14
publication date: 2025-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 74
ending page: 87
doi: 10.33043/wdhdMhNW

Why Structuralism Fails in Interpreting Visual Art
type: item
description: This paper critically examines the application of structuralism as a method of interpreting visual art, with a focus on Jacques Derrida’s critique of the concept of the frame as presented in La vérité en peinture. Structuralist methodology seeks to interpret artworks through segmentation and analysis of internal relations. However, Derrida’s notion of the frame challenges the feasibility of defining clear boundaries between an artwork and its context, thereby undermining the foundational premises of structuralist interpretation. By constructing an argument based on these Derridean reflections on the frame, this study highlights the conceptual limitations of structuralism when extended to visual arts.
creator: Alexander Bak
rights: Copyright (c) 2025 Alexander Bak https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2025-04-14
publication date: 2025-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 32
ending page: 43
doi: 10.33043/GwDP9hx9

Towards an Account of Complementarities and Context-Dependence
type: item
description: Modern physics proposals present deep tensions between seemingly contradictory descriptions of reality. Views of wave-particle duality, black hole complementarity, and the Unruh effect demand explanations that shift depending on how a system is observed. However, traditional models of scientific explanation impose a fixed structure that fails to account for varying observational contexts. This paper introduces context-dependent mapping, a framework that reorganizes physical laws into self-consistent subsets structured around what can actually be observed in a given context. By doing so, it provides a principled way to integrate complementarity into the philosophy of explanation.
creator: Hong Joo Ryoo
rights: Copyright (c) 2025 Hong Joo Ryoo https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2025-04-14
publication date: 2025-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 44
ending page: 59
doi: 10.33043/YMCGR3hB

Do My Signals Deceive Me?
type: item
description: An interview with Jorge Morales to discuss his work with a focus on mental strength, signal detection theory, and philsophy's relationship to science.
creator: Connor Dull
creator: Jorge Morales
rights: Copyright (c) 2024 Connor Dull, Jorge Morales https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2024-04-06
publication date: 2024-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 122
ending page: 139

The Rending of the Veil: Tarrying with the Technological Sublime
type: item
description: The potentially philosophically problematic aspects of modern technology have been the subject of much discourse in recent times. The new kinds of incorporeal online spaces that are available to engage with have untold consequences on the formation of subjectivity. When phenomenological arguments about the nature of being are considered, the way that we display ourselves online becomes in need of exploration. This paper hypothesizes an exploration of what new relations toward the world have arisen through our relation to the sublime in technology. To this end, we must examine how deeply the feeling of the sublime in technology has affected subjectivity and intelligence.
creator: Sam Gourlay
rights: Copyright (c) 2025 Sam Gourlay https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2025-04-14
publication date: 2025-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 88
ending page: 99
doi: 10.33043/GzMc57G3

Nietzsche and the Birth of Joker
type: item
description: In The Birth of Tragedy, Nietzsche employs the dichotomy of Apollonian and Dionysian to explain artistic phenomena. The film Joker shows the origin story of the Joker, a comic-book supervillain. This paper offers a reading of Joker through Nietzsche’s ideas from The Birth of Tragedy. By doing so, it aims to achieve three things: first, to demonstrate the relevance of Nietzsche’s aesthetic theory in analyzing culture; second, to reveal the political dimension of Nietzsche’s thought in The Birth of Tragedy; and third, to shed light on the ominous implications of Joker’s popularity.
creator: Younghyun Hwang
rights: Copyright (c) 2024 Younghyun Hwang https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2024-04-06
publication date: 2024-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 50
ending page: 61
doi: 10.33043/S.17.1.50-61

The Relevance of Embodied Practice to Philosophical Understanding
type: item
description: In this paper I argue that meditation has a direct bearing upon philosophical discourse by enabling us to distance ourselves from the basic structure of subjectivity that often limits the scope of reason. Recent neurobiological hypotheses are discussed in conjunction with the method of hermeneutic phenomenology to argue that interpretations on the level of our neurobiology underly and construct our experience of ourselves as subjects and the sense of explicit rational understanding that arises from it. This implies that prediscursive embodied practice can play a crucial role in freeing our philosophical understanding from implicit assumptions.
creator: Hieronymus Wold
rights: Copyright (c) 2024 Hieronymus Wold https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2024-04-06
publication date: 2024-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 62
ending page: 73
doi: 10.33043/S.17.1.62-73

More Than We Can Chew
type: item
description: Western cultural norms resulting from patriarchal oppression contribute to the development of eating disorders in women. As represented by various philosophers, social factors can contribute to self-discipline of the body, which characterizes most image-based eating disorders. Critics of fundamental texts argue over the best way to engage in feminist discussion concerning these eating disorders, given that anorectics are often excluded from mainstream discourse. This paper proposes that the feminist community must approach conversations about eating disorders in three steps: recognition, sympathy, and acknowledgement. This is the only way that we can move towards addressing the cultural causes of individual pathologies.
creator: August Vitarbo
rights: Copyright (c) 2024 August Vitarbo https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2024-04-06
publication date: 2024-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 86
ending page: 97
doi: 10.33043/S.17.1.86-97

The Formation of Body Memory Under Patriarchy
type: item
description: Within this essay, I seek to understand how the patriarchy impacts the concept of body memory and creates gendered bodily behaviors. I first explain and define the relationship between one’s incorporative memory and affective framing. Given this relationship, I explore what male validation is and how it becomes embodied. I argue that the formation of the incorporative memory and affective framing under the patriarchy creates an embodied experience of male validation. As women begin to understand gender roles, they shift how they move their bodies, and continue to display this gendered movement because men validate it.
creator: Valencia White
rights: Copyright (c) 2024 Valencia White https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2024-04-06
publication date: 2024-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 74
ending page: 85
doi: 10.33043/S.17.1.74-85

A Good Little Girl is One Who Grows Up to Be a Woman
type: item
description: In today’s evolving understanding of gender, questions arise about the future of the feminist movement. Using Simone de Beauvoir’s The Second Sex, Hugh Ryan's “Who's Afraid of Social Contagion,” and Ben Kesslen’s “How the Idea of a 'Transgender Contagion' Went Viral—and Caused Untold Harm,” this paper explores the concept of the Other to analyze social contagion and gender-based oppression. It argues that while feminism must adapt, its future lies in embracing the experiences of all classified as the Other. Through de Beauvoir's work, historical definitions of gender, and social constructivism, this paper proposes a new idea for the future of feminism.
creator: Jemima Abalogu
rights: Copyright (c) 2024 Jemima Abalogu https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2024-04-06
publication date: 2024-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 98
ending page: 109
doi: 10.33043/S.17.1.98-109

A Phenomenological Approach to Legal Epistemic Injustice
type: item
description: Injustices in legal contexts are widespread, yet we usually tend to think of them through a social lens. The study of epistemic injustices increases the resolution of this lens; it identifies how we wrong others as "knowers." In this paper, I propose that the tradition of phenomenology may be invoked to describe and identify instances of epistemic injustice in legal contexts. In order to justify this claim, I establish a phenomenological methodology predicated on the synthesis of two ideas: (1) the phenomenological recognition of the Other, and (2) society's duty to endow its members with an epistemic sphere of action.
creator: Christopher Phillippe-Rodriguez
rights: Copyright (c) 2024 Christopher Phillippe-Rodriguez https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2024-04-06
publication date: 2024-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 12
ending page: 25
doi: 10.33043/S.17.1.12-25

In Defense of Immoralism
type: item
description: This paper investigates whether an ethical flaw in an artwork can be an aesthetic merit. I explore two versions of immoralism from Eaton and Kieran. I will defend the immoralist claim that artworks containing rough heroes are ethically flawed. I will then argue that an indirect connection between an ethical flaw and aesthetic merit is sufficient for immoralism, so long as it is a necessary connection. On this understanding of immoralism, I will argue that Eaton and Kieran are both successful in showing that an ethical flaw in an artwork can make it aesthetically better.
creator: Claire Bronwen Herbert
rights: Copyright (c) 2024 Claire Bronwen Herbert https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2024-04-06
publication date: 2024-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 26
ending page: 37
doi: 10.33043/S.17.1.26-37

On the Essence of Thought Experiments
type: item
description: Thought experiments feature prominently in both scientific and philosophical methods. In this paper, I investigate two questions surrounding knowledge in the thought experiment process. First, on what implicit knowledge do thought experiments rely? Second, what provides epistemic justification for beliefs acquired through the process? I draw upon neo-Aristotelian metaphysics and Husserlian phenomenology to argue that essence is the object of implicit knowledge that anchors the imagined possibilities involved in thought experiments to the actual world, and that this essentialist knowledge enables the possibility of prima facie justification being conferred by the phenomenological givenness of thought experiment scenarios.
creator: Hayden Macklin
rights: Copyright (c) 2024 Hayden Macklin https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2024-04-06
publication date: 2024-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 110
ending page: 121
doi: 10.33043/S.17.1.110-121

Science and the Question of Truth
type: item
description: The pursuit of scientific truth has long engaged philosophers of science. Miriam Solomon’s work in Social Empiricism introduces "Whig realism," which proposes that empirical success in science reflects some underlying truths within theories. This paper examines Solomon’s argument and discusses its response to a traditional scientific realism argument. I then critique Solomon’s treatment of decision vectors and their usage in determining when dissent is normatively appropriate. I conclude that, while Solomon’s framework provides some insights into the dynamics of scientific progress, concerns arise regarding its application.
creator: Pranav Vadlamudi
rights: Copyright (c) 2024 Pranav Vadlamudi https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
date: 2024-04-06
publication date: 2024-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 38
ending page: 49
doi: 10.33043/S.17.1.38-49

Back End
type: item
description: Artwork Index, Supporters
creator: Stance
rights: Copyright (c) 2023 Stance https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2023-04-06
publication date: 2023-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 118
ending page: 121

Front End
type: item
description: About the Cover, Staff, Acknowledgements, Table of Contents
creator: Stance
rights: Copyright (c) 2023 Stance https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2023-04-06
publication date: 2023-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 2
ending page: 11

Language, Feminism, and Racism
type: item
description: Jennifer Saul is Waterloo Chair in Social and Political Philosophy of Language at the University of Waterloo. Originally American, she spent twenty-four years at the University of Sheffield in the United Kingdom. Her current focus is manipulative political language, which she explores in Dogwhistles and Figleaves: Linguistics Tricks for Racist and Conspiracist Discourse (forthcoming, Oxford, 2024). She has also written books and articles on feminism, lying and misleading, and implicit bias. She founded the blogs What is it Like to be a Woman in Philosophy and Feminist Philosophers, and was Director of the Society for Women in Philosophy UK 2009–19. Along with Helen Beebee, she published two reports (in 2011 and 2021) on the state of women in philosophy in the UK and drew up good practice guidelines which have been adopted by dozens of departments. She’s also proud of having been a philosophical consultant on a zombie movie.
creator: Cecilia Becker
creator: Jennifer Saul
rights: Copyright (c) 2023 Jennifer Saul https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2023-04-06
publication date: 2023-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 98
ending page: 117
doi: 10.33043/S.16.1.98-117

On the Governance of Women’s Rights in Taliban Afghanistan
type: item
description: Since the Taliban resumed political power in Afghanistan in August 2021, their total application of strict Sharia Law has demanded global attention. This paper theorizes that, in pursuit of social order, the Taliban has enacted a civil religion to justify their complete reversion of women’s rights as a public good. I examine Afghanistan's social contact through the political philosophies of Thomas Hobbes and Jean-Jacques Rousseau and suggest why the intended social order has not materialized. In conclusion, I depict the erosion of women's rights as a matter of structural injustice and incite critical reflexivity towards our responsibility for global justice.
creator: Molly Graham
rights: Copyright (c) 2023 Molly Graham https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2023-04-06
publication date: 2023-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 84
ending page: 97
doi: 10.33043/S.16.1.84-97

The Rule of Law and Jury Trials
type: item
description: In The Rule of Law in the Real World, Paul Gowder presents a new account of the rule of law based on three conditions: publicity, regularity, and generality. In this essay, I examine two closely related questions that are prompted by Gowder’s version of the rule of law. First, does the rule of law require citizens to follow the law? Second, what does Gowder’s account mean for jury nullification? I argue that the rule of law does not require citizens to follow the law, but it does prohibit jury nullification. A discussion of some moral implications and objections follow.
creator: Raymond Peters
rights: Copyright (c) 2023 Raymond Peters https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2023-04-06
publication date: 2023-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 72
ending page: 83
doi: 10.33043/S.16.1.72-83

Escaping Self-Sacrifice
type: item
description: This work “Escaping Self-Sacrifice: Changing Black Women’s Relationship with Servility” is a deep dive into Lisa Tessman’s Burdened Virtues. Addressing the idea of servility as a burdened virtue that requires self-sacrifice, I strive to reevaluate the traditional role Black women have in their families and within their communities. I argue that the demands of Black women are so excessive that they have lost touch with their self-regarding virtues, causing them to have ethical imbalances within themselves. This work is a part of an ongoing attempt to counter oppressive practices with joy as a form of resistance. I use the idea that simply existing is enough for Black women without the added burden of taking care of everyone else.
creator: Aniyah Marie Daley
rights: Copyright (c) 2023 Aniyah Marie Daley https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2023-04-06
publication date: 2023-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 62
ending page: 71
doi: 10.33043/S.16.1.62-71

Autistic Students within the Community of Inquiry
type: item
description: The standard pedagogy within Philosophy for Children courses is the community of inquiry. In this paper, I argue that the current form of the community of inquiry does not properly accommodate autistic students. Using observations from Benjamin Lukey alongside my personal testimony, I illustrate how autistic students may struggle within the community of inquiry. Importantly, I argue that this need not be the case, as the community of inquiry can be made more inclusive if it were to emphasize collaboration instead of verbal dialogue.
creator: Rylan Garwood
rights: Copyright (c) 2023 Rylan Garwood https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2023-04-06
publication date: 2023-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 50
ending page: 61
doi: 10.33043/S.16.1.50-61

Shapeshifting
type: item
description: In this paper I explain the utility of shapeshifting through the figure of the sage and the nepantlera according to the Zhuangzi and “the path of conocimiento. . . inner work, public acts,” respectively. These two figures could serve as guidelines to protecting subjective truth in a tumultuous and egoistic time, and aid in defense against mental assimilation into normative cultures. A distinction between the two will be made, with emphasis on how the contextual development of the figures applies to different social situations, and a synthesis of the utility of their application in present day will follow. The process of shapeshifting, of not clinging to social custom and normative identity categories as a means to protect ourselves from mental harm and assimilation, may serve to be of some use to us all.
creator: Madelyn Huerkamp
rights: Copyright (c) 2023 Madelyn Huerkamp https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2023-04-06
publication date: 2023-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 38
ending page: 49
doi: 10.33043/S.16.1.38-49

Addressing Crimes of Passion with the Deep-Self View of Moral Responsibility
type: item
description: In this paper, I summarize and object to the “deep-self” view of moral responsibility as laid out by Susan Wolf in “Sanity and the Metaphysics of Responsibility.” My objection centers on how our intuitions regarding crimes of passion conflict with the conclusions drawn by the deep-self view. I then proceed to sketch out three possible responses which can be made by an adherent to the deep-self view and make my recommendations on how such adherents should proceed in further understanding moral responsibility.
creator: Elijah Parish
rights: Copyright (c) 2023 Elijah Parish https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2023-04-06
publication date: 2023-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 26
ending page: 37
doi: 10.33043/S.16.1.26-37

Sanjiao Heyi and Tibet
type: item
description: This paper considers Chinese Communist Party policies in Tibet from Confucian, Daoist, and Buddhist perspectives. I first explain how these three traditions are unified in the sanjiao heyi, but I contend that this practice has been neglected in favor of state repression. I then elucidate Confucianism, Daoism, and Buddhism with respect to their general principles and application in Tibet. I conclude that a fuller embrace of the sanjiao heyi where Confucian tenets are balanced by insights from Daoism and Buddhism would cultivate an anti-oppressive response to governmental control.
creator: Ty Rossow
rights: Copyright (c) 2023 Ty Rossow https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2023-04-06
publication date: 2023-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 12
ending page: 25
doi: 10.33043/S.16.1.12-25

Back End
type: item
description: Artwork Index, Supporters
creator: Stance
rights: Copyright (c) 2022 Stance https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2022-04-19
publication date: 2022-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 144
ending page: 147

Music, Cage's Silence, and Art
type: item
description: Stephen Davies taught philosophy at the University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand. His research specialty is the philosophy of art. He is a former President of the American Society for Aesthetics. His books include Definitions of Art (Cornell UP, 1991), Musical Meaning and Expression (Cornell UP, 1994), Musical Works and Performances (Clarendon, 2001), Themes in the Philosophy of Music (OUP, 2003), Philosophical Perspectives on Art (OUP, 2007), Musical Understandings and Other Essays on the Philosophy of Music (OUP, 2011), The Artful Species: Aesthetics, Art, and Evolution (OUP, 2012), The Philosophy of Art (Wiley-Blackwell, 2016 second ed.), and Adornment: What Self-decorations Tells Us about Who We Are, (Bloomsbury Academic, 2020).
creator: Grace Georgi
rights: Copyright (c) 2022 Grace Georgi https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2022-04-19
publication date: 2022-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 120
ending page: 143
doi: 10.33043/S.15.1.120-143

Kantian Disregard for Non-Rational Humans
type: item
description: I seek to emphasize Immanuel Kant’s lingering and unsavory impact on medical ethics by emphasizing Kantian ethics’ disregard for non- rational humans. We must be considerate when discussing individuals who have some form of dementia, conditions that irreversibly diminish the ability to use rational thought, sometimes to a degree of severity that hinders essential daily functions. I argue that to consider ourselves proponents of human equality we must treat humans with dementia as members of the kingdom of ends.
creator: Jay Six
rights: Copyright (c) 2022 Jay Six https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2022-04-19
publication date: 2022-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 112
ending page: 119
doi: 10.33043/S.15.1.112-119

How a Buddha Acts
type: item
description: Buddhist philosophers generally hold that concepts like “I” and “me,” while useful in everyday life, are ultimately meaningless. Under this view, there would be no “agents” because it is meaningless to say “I did so and so....” How do we explain the occurrence of actions without referring to agents? I argue that Cappelen and Dever’s Action Inventory Model (AIM) is a useful resource for developing a Buddhist theory of action. In response to an objection that AIM cannot explain a buddha’s action, I show that a slightly tweaked version of AIM succeeds in explaining how a buddha acts.
creator: Mukund Maithani
rights: Copyright (c) 2022 Mukund Maithani https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2022-04-19
publication date: 2022-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 100
ending page: 111
doi: 10.33043/S.15.1.100-111

Putnam's Problem of the Robot and Extended Minds
type: item
description: In this paper, I consider Hilary Putnam’s argument for the prima facie acceptance of robotic consciousness as deserving the status of mind. I argue that such an extension of consciousness renders the category fun- damentally unintelligible, and we should instead understand robots as integral products of an extended human conscious- ness. To this end, I propose a test from con- ceptual object permanence, which can be applied not just to robots, but to the in- numerable artifacts of consciousness that texture our existences.
creator: Jacob Berk
rights: Copyright (c) 2022 Jacob Berk https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2022-04-19
publication date: 2022-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 88
ending page: 99
doi: 10.33043/S.15.1.88-99

Thinking and Speaking
type: item
description: Based on Eli Alshanetsky’s work Articulating a Thought, in this paper, I present a reconstructed puzzle involving complex thoughts and a method for how to tackle articulating them. Then, I reconstruct and provide objections to Alshanetsky’s favored view with rationality. I expound on an initially overlooked deflationary view that is arguably much more viable, while also adding a layer of nuance and granularity to the view that affirms its place in solving the puzzle. I reach the conclusion that if articulation is simply a medium for us to express our complex unfinished thoughts, then perhaps it isn’t necessary for us to clarify the thought.
creator: Vaibhav Gaddam
rights: Copyright (c) 2022 Vaibhav Gaddam https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2022-04-19
publication date: 2022-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 78
ending page: 87
doi: 10.33043/S.15.1.78-87

Bringing the Marginalized into Epistemology
type: item
description: In this paper, I discuss the epistemological injustices that Black women face in academia. I review Patricia Hill Collins’s work, “Learning from the Outsider Within: Sociological Significance of Black Feminist Thought,” which details the unique knowledge standpoint that Black women possess. I build upon the ideas set forth by Collins and other scholars to understand how the traditional knowledge validation process is tainted with political implications and harms Black women. I then offer recommendations rooted in alternative epistemology principles to combat the injustices inherent in academia.
creator: Kelly Oduro
rights: Copyright (c) 2022 Kelly Oduro https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2022-04-19
publication date: 2022-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 68
ending page: 77
doi: 10.33043/S.15.1.68-77

On the Structure of Consciousness
type: item
description: Some views of holism fail to fully encapsulate the structure and independence of consciousness while others are reductionist in their insistence on a strict structure. After examining holism and mental state consciousness, I move to my own proposal for the structure of consciousness: experiential swaths. By highlighting the phenomenal interdependence of some aspects of consciousness without conceding that all aspects are so strongly intertwined, experiential swaths allow for further conceptual structurization within consciousness.
creator: Shir Bloch
rights: Copyright (c) 2022 Shir Bloch https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2022-04-19
publication date: 2022-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 56
ending page: 67
doi: 10.33043/S.15.1.56-67

Is J.S. Mill's Account of Free Speech Sustainable in the Age of Social Media?
type: item
description: In this paper, I examine whether John Stuart Mill’s account of free speech can survive three main challenges posed by social media. First, I consider the problem of social media failing to distinguish between emotive and factual language. Second, I look at the problem of algorithms creating moralism. I then turn to a potential objection to my first two challenges. The objection elucidates the benefits of social media’s emotional and algorithmic character, amplifying arguments and increasing public engagement. However, I take issue with this objection on consequentialist terms. I finally return to the third challenge, where I focus on how anonymity removes the consequences to our words; I contend that this final failure is the ultimate reason why Mill’s account cannot persist in the modern age. In conclusion, I argue that Mill’s account cannot withstand the problems posed by social media.
creator: Nevin Chellappah
rights: Copyright (c) 2022 Nevin Chellappah https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2022-04-19
publication date: 2022-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 44
ending page: 55
doi: 10.33043/S.15.1.44-55

The Case Against Speciesism and Sexism
type: item
description: Using the interactionist approach of comparative philosophy, I evaluate the intersecting points made in Animal Liberationby Peter Singer and The Sexual Politics of Meat: A Feminist-Vegetarian Critical Theory by Carol Adams. The purpose of this paper is to examine how a combination of the utilitarian and feminist perspectives helps us adopt a new philosophy accounting for all systems of oppression involved in eating animals. I conclude that by removing unnecessary harm to animals and unlearning phrases with an absent reference to oppressed groups, society can progress toward an anti-oppressive system of liberation.
creator: Kelsey Gaylord
rights: Copyright (c) 2022 Kelsey Gaylord https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2022-04-19
publication date: 2022-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 32
ending page: 43
doi: 10.33043/S.15.1.32-43

The Wisdom of Wizards
type: item
description: In this paper, I explore the cognitive value of fantasy literature. Using Immanuel Kant's and Jean-Paul Sartre's discussions of the imagination, and J.R.R. Tolkien's "On Fairy Stories,” I argue that fantasy literature is cognitively valuable when it confers phenomenal knowledge. I move on to demonstrate what a work of fantasy literature requires to confer this phenomenal knowledge. Fantasy literature has the potential to reveal true insights into this world when it brings the reader into a state of “secondary belief” and confers phenomenal knowledge through the union of world and story.
creator: Greyson Gold
rights: Copyright (c) 2022 Greyson Gold https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2022-04-19
publication date: 2022-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 20
ending page: 31
doi: 10.33043/S.15.1.20-31

Front End
type: item
description: About the Cover, Staff, Acknowledgments, Table of Contents
creator: Stance
rights: Copyright (c) 2022 Stance https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2022-04-19
publication date: 2022-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 1
ending page: 11

Why Does God Need Freedom?
type: item
description: God is often portrayed as being omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent. Many worry that these traits make it so that God cannot possess free will. However, very little is said about why a God without freedom would be an issue. I argue that God does not need the kind of freedom we usually care about. I make a case that free will is important to us because it allows us to assign blame and praise to others. From here, I argue that being able to blame God is unimportant, and that God can still be praised even without free will.
creator: Klayton Silverpen
rights: Copyright (c) 2022 Klayton Silverpen https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2022-04-19
publication date: 2022-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 12
ending page: 19
doi: 10.33043/S.15.1.12-19

Back End
type: item
description: Artwork Index, Supporters
creator: Stance
rights: Copyright (c) 2021 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2021-04-06
publication date: 2021-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 168
ending page: 171

Front End
type: item
description: About the Cover, Staff, Acknowledgments, Table of Contents
creator: Stance
rights: Copyright (c) 2021 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2021-04-06
publication date: 2021-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 1
ending page: 12

Origin, Impact, and Reaction to Misogynistic Behaviors
type: item
description: Kate A. Manne is an associate professor at the Sage School of Philosophy at Cornell University, where she has been teaching since 2013. Before that, she was a junior fellow at the Harvard Society of Fellows (2011–2013), did her graduate work at MIT (2006–2011), and was an undergraduate at the University of Melbourne (2001–2005), where she studied philosophy, logic, and computer science. Her current research is primarily in moral, feminist, and social philosophy. She is the author of two books, including her first book Down Girl: The Logic of Misogyny and her latest book Entitled: How Male Privilege Hurts Women. Manne has also published a number of scholarly papers about the foundations of morality, and she regularly writes opinion pieces, essays, and reviews in venues—including The New York Times, The Boston Review, the Huffington Post, and the Chronicle of Higher Education.
creator: Brianna Lopez
creator: Kate A. Manne
rights: Copyright (c) 2021 Kate Manne https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2021-04-06
publication date: 2021-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 147
ending page: 167
doi: 10.33043/S.14.1.147-167

Post-Hierarchical Race
type: item
description: In this essay, I consider Sally Haslanger’s social constructivist account of race and propose a modification to the nature of hierarchy specified. According to Haslanger, race will cease to exist post-hierarchy, given that she builds in a requirement of synchronic hierarchy for the existence of race. While Haslanger maintains that racial identity would linger beyond hierarchical treatment in the form of ethnicity, I will suggest this fails to provide adequate conceptual justice for the cultures and aesthetics which emerged out of past oppression. In response, I propose a modification which would allow us to recognize the possibility of post-hierarchical races.
creator: Max Davidson-Smith
rights: Copyright (c) 2021 Max Davidson-Smith https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2021-04-06
publication date: 2021-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 135
ending page: 145
doi: 10.33043/S.14.1.135-145

Why the Readiness Potential Does Not Disprove Free Will
type: item
description: Neuroscientist Benjamin Libet has conducted a series of experiments that reveal the existence of certain neural processes in the brain of human subjects, initiating an action prior to the human subject’s intention to act, thus seemingly threatening our idea of free will. The purpose of this paper is to show how these processes do not disprove any idea of free will one might have as one would, if accepting such a thesis, be committing two distinct mereological fallacies and ultimately, would treat the human subject as inhabiting some of its parts as opposed to being the sum of its parts.
creator: Even Totland
rights: Copyright (c) 2021 Even Totland https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2021-04-06
publication date: 2021-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 125
ending page: 133
doi: 10.33043/S.14.1.125-133

Avoiding the Swine
type: item
description: What constitutes a good life? A hedonist’s answer to this question is rather simple— more pleasure, less pain. While hedonism was previously a widely accepted belief, it now suffers from several crucial objections. A challenge particularly vexing to hedonists is the Philosophy of Swine: could it be possible that our lives may be less than that of a theoretical swine? In this essay, I argue that lifetime hedonism, the view of hedonism concerned with one’s total lifelong well-being, does not survive this objection. In particular, I will refute the counterarguments that modern-day hedonist, Ben Bramble, presents against the Philosophy of Swine objection.
creator: Jee Won Choi
rights: Copyright (c) 2021 Jee Won Choi https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2021-04-06
publication date: 2021-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 115
ending page: 123
doi: 10.33043/S.14.1.115-123

In Defense of Platonic Essentialism About Numbers
type: item
description: In defense of anti-essentialism, pragmatist Richard Rorty holds that we may think of all objects as if they were numbers. I find that Rorty’s metaphysics hinges on two rather weak arguments against the essences of numbers. In contrast, Plato’s metaphysics offers a plausible definition of essentiality by which numbers do have essential properties. Further, I argue that Rorty’s argumentative mistake is mischaracterizing Plato’s definition. I conclude that Plato’s definition of “essential” is a robust one which implies that many properties, beyond those we might intuitively think of, can count as essential properties of objects.
creator: Megan Wu
rights: Copyright (c) 2021 Megan Wu https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2021-04-06
publication date: 2021-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 103
ending page: 113
doi: 10.33043/S.14.1.103-113

Hegel's Projected Nihilism
type: item
description: Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel’s historical analysis of Buddhist philosophy not only fails as a sound interpretation of that tradition, it also well-exemplifies the Western practice of Orientalism as elucidated by Edward Said. I attempt to demonstrate this in three major parts: the nature of Orientalism as a concept and practice, the Orientalist analytical process that Hegel employs in judging Buddhism as well as religions in general, and how Hegel’s understanding does not work against a more charitably interpreted Buddhist defense. Moreover, I argue that the Orientalist erroneousness of Hegel’s reading deeply complicates his hierarchical philosophy of world history.
creator: Ryan Curnow
rights: Copyright (c) 2021 Ryan Curnow https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2021-04-06
publication date: 2021-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 91
ending page: 101
doi: 10.33043/S.14.1.91-101

Clashing Consciousness
type: item
description: In this paper, I consider practical strategies for resolving the epistemic injustice that ill persons face when seeking medical treatment. My arguments will expand upon those initially made by Havi Carel and Ian James Kidd in “Epistemic Injustice in Healthcare: A Philosophical Analysis.” My approach to this problem is twofold. First, I will demonstrate how the phenomenological toolkit, as it currently stands, emphasizes the patient’s experience and leaves the doctor’s experience unadjusted. After this, I will explain how the toolkit can be improved to include the doctor’s perspective.
creator: Bradley Holder
rights: Copyright (c) 2021 Bradley Holder https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2021-04-06
publication date: 2021-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 79
ending page: 89
doi: 10.33043/S.14.1.79-89

Being Moral Isn't Quite Enough
type: item
description: Attempts to define morality or stress its importance are the center of ethical debates that aim to provide guidance for human life. Deviating from this goal, Susan Wolf shines a light on the significance of “nonmoral virtues” by discussing how a moral saint’s life, too immersed in morality, could be lacking in other spheres. She states that a moral saint’s life would be unattractive or dull, as one is not able to value or pursue nonmoral activities such as the arts or cooking due to one’s commitments under moral sainthood. I challenge this argument, which belittles moral sainthood in an attempt to give more credit to nonmoral qualities in life, by arguing that nonmoral virtues could be necessary and valuable for a moral saint in carrying out her duties.
creator: Seyeong Hanlim
rights: Copyright (c) 2021 Seyeong Hanlim https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2021-04-06
publication date: 2021-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 67
ending page: 77
doi: 10.33043/S.14.1.67-77

Full Blooded Conceptual Realism as a Response to Skeptical Relativism
type: item
description: In this paper, I discuss full-blooded Platonism (the claim that all possible mathematical objects exist) as a response to the skeptical problem in the philosophy of mathematics as to how empirical beings can cognize non-empirical mathematical objects. I then attempt to develop an analogous position regarding the applicability of concepts to reality in response to the skeptical problem regarding how we can cognize an objective reality through human-constructed concepts. If all concepts meeting certain minimal conditions structure reality under some aspect, then objective knowledge is possible, regardless of how these concepts arose historically.
creator: Micah Phillips-Gary
rights: Copyright (c) 2021 Micah Phillips-Gary https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2021-04-06
publication date: 2021-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 53
ending page: 65
doi: 10.33043/S.14.1.53-65

Black Women in Fanon's Black Skin, White Masks
type: item
description: In this paper, I focus on the representations of Black women in contrast to Black men found within Frantz Fanon’s philosophical work Black Skin, White Masks. I propose that while Fanon’s racial dialectical work is very significant, he often lacks acknowledgment of the multidimensionality of the Black woman’s lived experience specifically. Drawing on the theory of intersectionality, coined by Kimberlé Crenshaw, I argue that Fanon does not recognize the different layers of oppression operating in Black women’s lives to the degree that he fails to include them within his framework of both liberation and resistance from racial oppression.
creator: Emma Ming Wahl
rights: Copyright (c) 2021 Emma Ming Wahl https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2021-04-06
publication date: 2021-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 41
ending page: 51
doi: 10.33043/S.14.1.41-51

A Two-Part Defense of Intuitionistic Mathematics
type: item
description: The classical interpretation of mathematical statements can be seen as comprising two separate but related aspects: a domain and a truth-schema. L. E. J. Brouwer’s intuitionistic project lays the groundwork for an alternative conception of the objects in this domain, as well as an accompanying intuitionistic truth-schema. Drawing on the work of Arend Heyting and Michael Dummett, I present two objections to classical mathematical semantics, with the aim of creating an opening for an alternative interpretation. With this accomplished, I then make the case for intuitionism as a suitable candidate to fill this void.
creator: Samuel Elliott
rights: Copyright (c) 2021 Samuel Elliott https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2021-04-05
publication date: 2021-04-05
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 27
ending page: 39
doi: 10.33043/S.14.1.27-39

The Plate is Political
type: item
description: In this paper, I investigate why anorexia nervosa emerged in non-Western nations after Western globalization efforts. Using Simone de Beauvoir’s theory of gender from The Second Sex alongside Michel Foucault’s conceptualization of the “docile body,” I argue that the emergence of anorexia nervosa in non-Western nations reflects the Western sovereign’s subordination of women. While patriarchal oppression is not exclusive to the West, I contend that the political ideology behind Western industrialization has allowed new avenues for patriarchal oppression to permeate. To conclude, I demand that mainstream discourse on anorexia nervosa consider the political conditions which are catalytic to its occurrence.
creator: Grace Weber
rights: Copyright (c) 2021 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2021-04-06
publication date: 2021-04-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 13
ending page: 25
doi: 10.33043/S.14.1.13-25

Supporters
type: item
description: N.A
creator: Zoe Lawson
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 178
ending page: 179

Philosophy as a Helping Profession
type: item
description: N.A
creator: Sid VanMeter
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 154
ending page: 177
doi: 10.33043/S.13.1.154-177

If There's No Music Up in Heaven Then What's it For?
type: item
description: In this article, I advocate in favor of music as a method of conveying philosophical thought, in the process defending subjective, non-verbal feeling as a component of true philosophical discussion. I first invoke the Kierkegaardian concepts of subjective truth and the musical-erotic to support my position, then show how such a method could be employed through a case study of the Arcade Fire song “Here Comes The Night Time.” Finally, I confront and disarm the potential accusation that this method would over-intellectualize music through excessive interpretation, removing the erotic nature that empowers it.
creator: Gabriel Tugendstein
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 142
ending page: 153
doi: 10.33043/S.13.1.142-153

Kripkenstein and Mathematics as the Language of Nature
type: item
description: This paper addresses the skeptical paradox highlighted in Saul Kripke’s work Wittgenstein on Rules and Private Language. The skeptical paradox stands in the way of many attempts to fix meaning in the rule-following of a language. This paper closely assesses the ‘straight solutions’ to this problem with regards to another type of language; mathematics. A conclusion is made that if we cannot sufficiently locate where the meaning lies in a mathematical operation; if we cannot describe how it is that we follow a rule in mathematics, we ought to tread lightly in characterising it as the language of nature.
creator: Nour Khairi
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 130
ending page: 141
doi: 10.33043/S.13.1.130-141

A Step Toward the Elucidation of Quantitative Laws of Nature
type: item
description: When we mathematically model natural phenomena, there is an assumption concerning how the mathematics relates to the actual phenomenon in question. This assumption is that mathematics represents the world by “mapping on” to it. I argue that this assumption of mapping, or correspondence between mathematics and natural phenomena, breaks down when we ignore the fine grain of our physical concepts. I show that this is a source of trouble for the mapping account of applied mathematics, using the case of Prandtl’s Boundary Layer solution to the Navier-Stokes equations.
creator: Stephen Perry
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 72
ending page: 83
doi: 10.33043/S.13.1.72-83

Problems of Framing
type: item
description: In “Fatalism and Time,” Mark Bernstein argues against the notion that the B-theory of time is fatalistic. However, when he frames the differences between the A-theory of time and the B-theory of time, I argue that Bernstein imports some troublesome conceptual baggage in the form of what he calls “atemporal truths,” which, in the end, dooms the B-theory to fatalism, the consequence he sought to avoid. From my examination of Bernstein’s framing of the B-theory of time, I suggest that, given the proper framing of that theory, it is not doomed to fatalism.
creator: Augustus Wachbrit
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 118
ending page: 129
doi: 10.33043/S.13.1.118-129

We Don't Know We Have Hands and it's Fine
type: item
description: Based on the brain in a vat thought experiment, skeptics argue that we cannot have certain knowledge. At the same time, we do have the intuition that we know some things with certainty. A way to justify this intuition is given by semantic contextualists who argue that the word “knows” is context sensitive. However, many have objected to the intelligibility of this claim. In response, another approach called “moderate pragmatic contextualism” was invoked, which claims that “knows” itself is not context sensitive, but knowledge assertions are. I show, however, that to refute skepticism, moderate pragmatic contextualism rests on unjustified and implausible assumptions as well. Since no form of contextualism works as a response to skepticism, I argue that we should simply accept skepticism. However, I argue that skepticism is not a problem because skeptic pragmatic contextualism can offer a plausible explanation of why we have the intuition that our ordinary knowledge claims are true, even though they are not. I conclude that skeptic pragmatic contextualism offers the most plausible response to the brain in a vat thought experiment.
creator: Nicolien Janssens
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 106
ending page: 117
doi: 10.33043/S.13.1.106-117

Fanon and Recognition
type: item
description: This paper applies Hegel’s master-slave dialectic to Fanon’s issue of pseudo-recognition discussed in the essay, “The Negro and Recognition,” as a way of establishing a form of self-consciousness. I begin the paper by arguing that in the Hegelian dialectic establishing a self-consciousness is an essential prerequisite to Fanon’s goal of mutual subject-recognition. I then argue that given the position of black people as slaves within the master-slave dialectic, they are denied the recognition required to attain being in-itself for-itself, which in reality can only be obtained if black people establish self-consciousness on their own terms. I then make the case that this required self- consciousness can only be obtained through struggle, essentially reversing the stages of the dialectic to create a new master/slave relation. In particular, I argue that this moment of struggle provides a moment of proto-recognition which can be used to build a new mutual subject-recognition. I then theorize on what form this new relation must take, making the case that it must be a relation where the categories of master and slave are made irrelevant, and where all subjects are capable of mutual recognition.
creator: Peter Visscher
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 96
ending page: 105
doi: 10.33043/S.13.1.96-105

Let's Talk About the Birds, Not the Bees
type: item
description: Just as math and history classes aim to prepare students to do math and history well, sex education must prepare students to participate in good sex that contributes to their overall flourishing. I reject David Archard’s autonomy-centered view of sex education because it fails to address deeply ingrained social inequalities. I deny Paula McAvoy’s mutuality-centered view of sex education because mutuality and consent are not sufficient for good sex. I draw on Quil Kukla’s work on sexual negotiation and claim that for sex to be good, we must engage in communicative sex that goes beyond consent. Therefore, sex education should not only instruct students how to avoid bad sex, but also enable students to participate in good sex that contributes to their overall flourishing.
creator: Grace Gecewicz
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 84
ending page: 95
doi: 10.33043/S.13.1.84-95

Not So Skeptical
type: item
description: In this essay, I look at two skeptical accounts of empathy that argue against our ability to imagine what it is like to be someone else but present alternative solutions to accomplish the same sort of human understanding. I will demonstrate how these solutions can encompass the imaginative process cattle-equipment- designer Temple Grandin describes undergoing while trying to imagine what it is like to be a cow. I then argue that Grandin’s exercise is a successful imagination of the other and because she uses the approaches described to achieve this, the accounts are not actually skeptical, and policymakers ought to adopt these sorts of practices.
creator: Allison Gould
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 62
ending page: 71
doi: 10.33043/S.13.1.62-71

How to Scrutinize the Market God
type: item
description: This essay aims to construct and demonstrate an analogical inter-disciplinary methodology. Developing the parallels between the God of classical theism and the modern market illustrated by Harvey Cox, I propose that neo-liberalism may be scrutinized as a philosophically understood entity. Debates within philosophy of religion may act as templates of scrutiny against the postmodern deity that is the neo-liberal market system. I aim to exemplify this method through the bedrock theological issue that is the Epicurean Paradox; just as philosophers produce theodicy, I contend that free-market fundamentalists need advocate laissez-faire in light of socio- economic suffering.
creator: Jerome Boyd
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 48
ending page: 61
doi: 10.33043/S.13.1.48-61

A Philosophical Analysis of AI and Racism
type: item
description: This paper addresses the problem of racism against Latinx and Black people in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and offers possible solutions. This ethical analysis is necessary because with a dramatic increase in the production of AI, the way we use it is critical in eliminating its current perpetuation of racism. I offer evidence of the current perpetuation of racism through AI by analyzing its use in banking and in law enforcement. I argue that the current way we produce and use AI needs to be seriously reconsidered and reinforce this argument with the use of Rawls’ theories of justice.
creator: Lel Jones
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 36
ending page: 47
doi: 10.33043/S.13.1.36-47

A Proposal for a Coherentist-Constitutivist Account of Normativity
type: item
description: We operate under norms of evaluating actions as good and bad, right and wrong, or reasonable and unreasonable. What justifies the authority of these norms? Christine Korsgaard takes the constitutivist position and argues that self-constitution, as the standard for what constitutes action, is the source of normativity. David Enoch argues that it is impossible for any constitutivist model to justify normative standards, and that realism is the best solution. In this paper, I demonstrate that the best solution to the tensions Enoch raises is not realism, but an original coherentist-constitutivist model of normativity rooted in Korsgaardian constitutivism.
creator: Yixue (Anna) Cheng
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 24
ending page: 35
doi: 10.33043/S.13.1.24-35

Love and Rationality
type: item
description: Much work has been done in contemporary epistemology to reconcile our epistemic ideals with our human need for healthy relationships with our loved ones. Ryan Preston-Roedder makes an attempt to resolve the tension between these two goals in his paper, “Three Varieties of Faith.” However, his account lacks the clarity necessary to make a thoroughly convincing argument. In this paper, I expand on Preston-Roedder’s ideas, distilling a novel account of epistemic partiality that allows us to maintain epistemic rationality without sacrificing elements of friendship that have a significant impact on our social and emotional well-being.
creator: Jude Cyr
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 12
ending page: 23
doi: 10.33043/S.13.1.12-23

Cover
type: item
description: N.A
creator: Sydney Smith
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1

Front End: Table of Contents and Staff
type: item
description: N.A
creator: Zoe Lawson
rights: Copyright (c) 2020 Zoe Lawson
date: 2020-04-14
publication date: 2020-04-14
volume: 18
number: 1

Ripping the Curtain
type: item
description: Peter Rollins is a writer, philosopher, storyteller and public speaker who has gained an international reputation for overturning traditional notions of religion and forming “churches” that preach the Good News that we can’t be satisfied, that life is difficult, and that we don’t know the secret. Challenging the idea that faith concerns questions relating to belief, Peter’s incendiary and irreligious reading of Christianity attacks the distinction between the sacred and the secular. It blurs the lines between theism and atheism and it sets aside questions regarding life after death to explore the possibility of life before death. Peter gained his higher education from Queens University, Belfast where he earned degrees (with distinction) in Scholastic Philosophy (BA Hons), Political Theory and Social Criticism (MA) and Post-Structural thought (PhD). He’s the author of numerous books, including Insurrection, The Idolatry of God, and The Divine Magician. He was born in Belfast, Northern Ireland, currently lives in Los Angeles and will die somewhere as yet not known.
creator: Peter Rollins
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-25
publication date: 2019-09-25
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 126
ending page: 145
doi: 10.33043/S.12.1.126-145

Double Consciousness in Today's Black America
type: item
description: In The Souls of Black Folk, W.E.B. Du Bois introduces double consciousness as a result of racial prejudice and oppression. Explained as a state of confliction felt by black Americans, Du Bois presents double consciousness as integral to understanding the black experience. Later philosophers question the importance of double consciousness to current race discussions, but this paper contends that double consciousness provides valuable insights into black and white relations. To do this, I will utilize the modern slang term, “Oreo,” to highlight how a perceived incompatibility between blacks and whites could prevent America from achieving a greater unity.
creator: L.E. Walker
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-25
publication date: 2019-09-25
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 116
ending page: 125
doi: 10.33043/S.12.1.116-125

A Pragmatic Look at Schopenhauer's Pessimism
type: item
description: Schopenhauer’s pessimistic philosophy is a depressing read. He writes many pages about how suffering is the norm, and any happiness we feel is merely a temporary alleviation of suffering. Even so, his account of suffering rings true to many readers. What are we to do with our lives if Schopenhauer is right, and we are doomed to suffer? In this paper, I use William James’ pragmatic method to find practical implications of Schopenhauer’s pessimism. I provide a model for how we are to live our lives in a suffering world, a model that provides means to reduce suffering.
creator: Allison Parker
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-25
publication date: 2019-09-25
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 106
ending page: 115
doi: 10.33043/S.12.1.106-115

The Necklace View of the Self
type: item
description: In this paper, I provide a framework for accounting for the self, based on a reconstruction of Galen Strawson’s “theory of SESMETs,” or the Pearl view, with Barry Dainton’s continuous consciousness thesis. I argue that the framework I provide adequately accounts for the self and is preferable to solely adopting either Strawson’s or Dainton’s theory. I call my reconstruction the “Necklace” view of the self.
creator: Yifeng Xu
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-25
publication date: 2019-09-25
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 96
ending page: 105
doi: 10.33043/S.12.1.96-105

A Fractal Universe and the Identity of Indiscernibles
type: item
description: The principle of Identity of Indiscernibles has been challenged with various thought experiments involving symmetric universes. In this paper, I describe a fractal universe and argue that, while it is not a symmetric universe in the classical sense, under the assumption of a relational theory of space it nonetheless contains a set of objects indiscernible by pure properties alone. I then argue that the argument against the principle from this new thought experiment resists better than those from classical symmetric universes three main objections put forth against this kind of arguments.
creator: Matteo Casarosa
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-25
publication date: 2019-09-25
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 86
ending page: 95
doi: 10.33043/S.12.1.86-95

Freeing Mysticism
type: item
description: With the growth of epistemology, an important debate in philosophy of religion has arisen: can mystical encounters—purported feelings of intense unity with the divine—serve as epistemic warrants? In this paper, I examine two of the most prominent and promising standards by which to determine the veridicality of such encounters—those of William Alston and Richard Swinburne—and demonstrate their respective strengths and shortcomings. Considering these shortcomings, I compose and defend my own set of criteria to use in evaluating the veridicality of putative mystical experiences which draws upon the subject’s religious tradition, rationality, and affectivity.
creator: John Cooney
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-25
publication date: 2019-09-25
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 74
ending page: 85
doi: 10.33043/S.12.1.74-85

The Fires of Change
type: item
description: In this paper, I explore a prominent question of Hericlitean scholarship: how is change possible? Karl Popper and G. S. Kirk tackle this same question. Kirk asserts that Heraclitus believed that change is present on a macrocosmic level and that all change is regulated by the cosmic principle logos. Popper, on the other hand, claims Heraclitus believed that change is microcosmic and rejected that all change is regulated by logos. I argue for a combination of aspects from each of their claims and conclude that change is present both microcosmically and macrocosmically and that all change is governed by logos.
creator: Holly Cooper
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-25
publication date: 2019-09-25
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 56
ending page: 63
doi: 10.33043/S.12.1.56-63

Domestic Imperialism
type: item
description: Frantz Fanon’s works have been invaluable in the analysis of colonies and the colonized subject’s mentality therein, but an analysis of the colonial power itself has been largely left to the wayside. The aim of this paper is to explicate a key element of Fanon’s theoretical framework, the metropolis/periphery dichotomy, then, using the writings of Huey P. Newton and Stokely Carmichael, among others, show its reversal within the colonial power. I will analyze this reversal in three ways: first, the reversal of the relationship between, and the roles of, the metropolis and periphery; second, the role of police and the differences between the colonial police and the police within the colonial power; and third, the modified role of prisons within the colonial power.
creator: J. Wolfe Harris
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-25
publication date: 2019-09-25
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 64
ending page: 73
doi: 10.33043/S.12.1.64-73

Mary Does Not Learn Anything New
type: item
description: Within the discourse surrounding mind-body interaction, mental causation is intimately associated with non-reductive physicalism. However, such a theory holds two opposing views: that all causal properties and relations can be explicated by physics and that special sciences have an explanatory role. Jaegwon Kim attempts to deconstruct this problematic contradiction by arguing that it is untenable for non-reductive physicalists to explain human behavior by appeal to mental properties. In combination, Kim’s critique of mental causation and the phenomenal concept strategy serves as an effectual response to the anti-physicalist stance enclosed within the Knowledge Argument and the Zombie Thought Experiment.
creator: Adam Khayat
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-25
publication date: 2019-09-25
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 44
ending page: 55
doi: 10.33043/S.12.1.44-55

Problems with the "Problems" with Psychophysical Causation
type: item
description: In this essay, I defend a mind-body dualism, according to which human minds are immaterial substances that exercise non-redundant causal powers over bodies, against the notorious problem of psychophysical causation. I explicate and reply to three formulations of the problem: (i) the claim that, on dualism, psychophysical causation is inconsistent with physical causal closure, (ii) the claim that psychophysical causation on the dualist view is intolerably mysterious, and (iii) Jaegwon Kim’s claim that dualism fails to account for causal pairings. Ultimately, I conclude that these objections fail and that dualist interactionism is no more problematic or mysterious than physical causation.
creator: Noah McKay
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-25
publication date: 2019-09-25
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 32
ending page: 43
doi: 10.33043/S.12.1.32-43

The Ethical Implications of The Intentional Fallacy
type: item
description: I argue that biographical information is akin to other non-aesthetic, social, historical, or political information. As such, artist’s biographies are always relevant and important when interpreting art. While the meaning and value of a piece of art is not determined by any single piece of contextual information, neither is its meaning and value ever entirely separated from context. In some cases, however, a piece of art that is technically magnificent may be experienced as repugnant when the artist has committed egregious acts.
creator: Rosanna Sparacino
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-25
publication date: 2019-09-25
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 22
ending page: 31
doi: 10.33043/S.12.1.22-31

Colour and The Argument from Illusion
type: item
description: For A. J. Ayer, the occurrence of delusions confutes the notion that we perceive the world directly. He argues instead that perceptions are caused by immaterial “sense data” which somehow represent the properties of material things to us in our experiences. J. L. Austin systematically rejects Ayer’s claims, arguing that the occurrence of delusions does not preclude the possibility of direct perception, and that, indeed, our normal perception is direct. I challenge both philosophers’ ideas by examining how they deal with the phenomenon of colour.
creator: Cameron Yetman
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-25
publication date: 2019-09-25
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 12
ending page: 21
doi: 10.33043/S.12.1.12-21

Thinking Just Happens
type: item
description: David Chalmers is a professor of philosophy and neural science at New York University. He received his PhD in philosophy and cognitive science from Indiana University in 1993 and has held positions at University of California, Santa Cruz, University of Arizona, and Australian National University. He helped to found the Association for the Scientific Study of Consciousness and co-directs the PhilPapers Foundation. Chalmers has written extensively on a wide range of topics, including philosophy of mind, philosophy of language, metaphysics, epistemology, and metaphilosophy. He is a prolific author. His well-known works include The Conscious Mind, The Character of Consciousness, and Constructing the World. For more information about Chalmers and his current projects, visit http://consc.net/.
creator: David Chalmers
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2018-04-23
publication date: 2018-04-23
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 132
ending page: 151
doi: 10.33043/S.11.1.132-151

The Diversity Initiative as Anti-Revolutionary Project
type: item
description: Through diversity initiatives, academia and business have recruited many new talented individuals from historically underrepresented communities. These institutions are now in the position of possessing, managing, and deploying a massive amount of diverse talent. We examine what we may expect from these institutions as they continue to absorb diverse talent, as well as what we can expect from these talented individuals as they become a newly established class.
creator: Gerald Nelson
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2018-04-23
publication date: 2018-04-23
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 118
ending page: 131
doi: 10.33043/S.11.1.118-131

Ideal Cognition
type: item
description: Both the nature and aim of human cognition are philosophically divisive topics. On one side, there are the evidentialists who believe that the sole purpose of cognition is to seek and find truths. In contrast, pragmatists appeal to cognition solely as a tool, something that helps people achieve their goals. In this paper, I put forward an account of cognition and its aims fundamentally based on a pragmatic viewpoint. Crucially, however, I claim that an evolutionary pragmatic picture of cognition must assert rationality as a core tenant of human thought, mooring a relative pragmatism within a system logic and rationality.
creator: Kate Kennedy
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2018-04-23
publication date: 2018-04-23
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 106
ending page: 117
doi: 10.33043/S.11.1.106-117

On Methodologies of Resisting Testimonial Injustice
type: item
description: Testimonial injustice, in its most pernicious form, subjects a speaker to identity-prejudicial deficits in the credibility that is rightly due their testimony. This paper compares two prominent accounts of testimonial injustice to determine which achieves the best understanding of the phenomenon and how it can be combatted. Where Fricker’s focus is limited to strictly epistemic wrongs, Medina’s analysis extends to the pertinent non-epistemic elements central to the injustice. Thus, Medina’s methodology is better-suited to the task of phenomenological analysis, and positions us to achieve a more complete understanding of what injustice has been perpetrated, and of how to resist it.
creator: Christopher Humphreys
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2018-04-23
publication date: 2018-04-23
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 92
ending page: 105
doi: 10.33043/S.11.1.92-105

Living with the Dying, Being-With the Dead
type: item
description: Though Heidegger largely informs his conceptions of being and time through an analytic of the phenomenology of death, he treats death as an entirely personal experience. Through Robert Pogue Harrison’s Dominion of the Dead, and Tolstoy’s The Death of Ivan Ilyich, this essay examines the death of others, and how the experience of another’s death informs the life of the living. The death of others is the possibility of a shift in the world of the living; this possibility for the living arises primarily through relationship with the corpse.
creator: Sam Traylor
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2018-04-23
publication date: 2018-04-23
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 80
ending page: 91
doi: 10.33043/S.11.1.80-91

The House Has Eyes
type: item
description: Human beings cannot bear the thought of no longer being the center of the universe; Martin Heidegger’s ontology validates the construction of a world that subjugates non-human objects to a role which reinforces our own position. In this paper, two personal experiences of objects which contradict traditional construals of “subjectivity” will be explored and analyzed in light of contemporary uncertainty around Heidegger’s ontology. Ultimately, I seek to complicate and show the radical dependence humans have on the constructed— or, “second”—subjectivity of objects and how we use them to validate the world as we wish it to be seen.
creator: Benjamin M. Slightom
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2018-04-23
publication date: 2018-04-23
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 68
ending page: 79
doi: 10.33043/S.11.1.68-79

Ceci N'est Pas Une Atheist
type: item
description: In The Gay Science Nietzsche famously writes that “God is dead.” Modern atheists, including “Internet Atheists,” have taken this as their epithet. I argue that the perpetuation of the statement “God is dead” contradicts the atheistic core, such that Internet Atheists parallel theists in identity construction. Insights from Nietzsche, Jean Luc Nancy, Sigmund Freud, and Christopher Hitchens allow for an exploration of the theistic underpinnings of Internet Atheists. The doctrine of Internet Atheism, as it is represented in humorous online depictions of God, suggests an inability to confront the consequences of the death of God, an inability which Nietzsche warns against in the Parable of the Madman.
creator: Emily Mastragostino
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2018-04-23
publication date: 2018-04-23
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 56
ending page: 67
doi: 10.33043/S.11.1.56-67

Critique and Intersubjectivity
type: item
description: In light of the allegations of sexual misconduct and harassment made against Harvey Weinstein and other powerful men in recent months, this paper will examine how men might take on responsibility for themselves and a culture that enables these patterns of abuse. It will draw primarily on the work of Judith Butler, Luce Irigaray, and Emmanuel Levinas to develop a model of responsibility that has three primary stages: taking ownership of past actions, critiquing gendered power relations, and learning how to foster relationships that are “intersubjective.”
creator: Dallas Jokic
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2018-04-23
publication date: 2018-04-23
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 46
ending page: 55
doi: 10.33043/S.11.1.46-55

Durkheim's Relational Account of Social Ontology
type: item
description: Secondary commentators on Emile Durkheim have interpreted his ontology in conflicting and contradictory ways. Some have claimed that he treats social entities as mysterious substances which exist over and above individuals. Others claim he is ontologically committed to exactly nothing more than individuals. Few studies have carefully analyzed his ontological commitments in detail, and the conventional wisdom on the issue leaves much to be desired. I argue Durkheim holds neither a substance nor an individualist view of social ontology. Instead, he is committed to the reality of emergent social relations which form the proper subject matter of sociology.
creator: Daniel Saunders
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2018-04-23
publication date: 2018-04-23
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 34
ending page: 45
doi: 10.33043/S.11.1.34-45

When Language Breaks
type: item
description: In “Logic and Conversation,” H. P. Grice posits that in conversations, we are “always-already” implying certain things about the subjects of our words while abiding by certain rules to aid in understanding. It is my view, however, that Grice’s so-called “cooperative principle” can be analyzed under the traditional Heideggerian dichotomy of ready-to-hand and presentat-hand wherein language can be viewed as a “mere” tool that sometimes breaks. Ultimately, I contend that the likening of language to a tool allows for a more robust understanding of it and conversational failures, while ontologically recategorizing language as an object of sorts.
creator: Peter Heft
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2018-04-23
publication date: 2018-04-23
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 22
ending page: 33
doi: 10.33043/S.11.1.22-33

Trans Men and Trans Women
type: item
description: This paper addresses one of the ways in which transgender individuals identify with respect to personal history, living “stealth,” whereby transgender individuals do not disclose their transgender status (that is, they present themselves as cisgender), oftentimes no longer considering themselves transgender. Individuals who live stealth are often criticized for inauthenticity; thus, this paper analyses Sartrean notions of authenticity and personal history, thereby arguing that the person who lives stealth is not living inauthentically but rather is constituting their conception of self through their past, present, and future projects.
creator: Julian Rome
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2018-04-23
publication date: 2018-04-23
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 10
ending page: 21
doi: 10.33043/S.11.1.10-21

The Philosopher's Role
type: item
description: Article published in Stance by McIntosh and Shafer-Landau.
creator: Benjamin McIntosh
creator: Russ Shafer-Landau
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2017-04-19
publication date: 2017-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 94
ending page: 109
doi: 10.33043/S.10.1.94-109

Making Sense of Epicurean Friendship
type: item
description: This paper argues that Epicurean friendship is instrumental in value, and Epicurus’s varied claims about friendship can be understood as teaching strategies that are tailored to different levels of students. After rejecting an argument that presents Epicurean friendship as intrinsic, I outline Epicurus’s methodology of teaching and examine his specific claims regarding friendship as intended for either novice, intermediate, or advanced students. This approach allows Epicurus’s weaker and stronger claims regarding friendship to be viewed as gradually progressing students towards the good life without deviating from the ethical hedonism that frames his entire philosophical project.
creator: Janice Perri
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2017-04-19
publication date: 2017-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 84
ending page: 93
doi: 10.33043/S.10.1.84-93

Semantic Ambiguity Explained in the Framework of Cognitive Economy
type: item
description: In “Context and Communication” Stephen Neale argues that the referential use of descriptions differs from the attributive use only in the pragmatics, making referential descriptions applicable to Russellian analysis. Marga Reimer disagrees with Neale’s view and argues that the difference is in the semantics, making referential descriptions semantically ambiguous. In this paper, I argue that Neale’s Modified Occam’s Razor overlooks the behavioral data of how we actually use language. I attempt to accommodate the strength of both Neale’s and Reimer’s explanations, putting them in a framework governed by the principle of cognitive economy
creator: Lixing Mida Chu
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2017-04-19
publication date: 2017-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 82
ending page: 93
doi: 10.33043/S.10.1.82-93

Virtual Enframing
type: item
description: Sherry Turkle’s “virtuous circle” will be used to bring insights from Heidegger and Levinas into accord. Turkle argues that the distraction and escape made possible by our devices tend to undermine achieving solitude and genuine sociality, thus posing a danger to the interdependent possibilities of authenticity and ethical living. For Heidegger, the call of conscience is one’s ownmost possibility, death. Levinas argues that the call of conscience is instead ethical, instigated by the face of the Other. Rather than conflicting, these two phenomenological accounts of conscience will be shown to be mutually affirming once brought into harmony via Turkle’s framework.
creator: David McKerracher
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2017-04-19
publication date: 2017-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 72
ending page: 83
doi: 10.33043/S.10.1.72-83

Cognition & Evolution
type: item
description: In this paper, I examine one of Nagel’s arguments against evolutionary theory, that the evolutionary conception of nature is incompatible with our understanding of cognition. I reconstruct Nagel’s two charges that the evolutionary conception of nature is at odds with our ability to acquire objective knowledge of the external world and that evolutionary theory is insufficient to explain logic’s absolute reliability. I reply to the first charge by suggesting that we should understand our ability to logically reason as a by-product instead of a direct product of the evolutionary processes. Then I reply to the second charge by denying that logic’s reliability is an appropriate subject of inquiry the evolutionary theory.
creator: Haiyu Jiang
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2017-04-19
publication date: 2017-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 60
ending page: 71
doi: 10.33043/S.10.1.60-71

Synthetic Biology and Natural Kinds
type: item
description: In the life sciences, biologists and philosophers lack a unifying concept of species—one that will reconcile intuitive demarcations of taxa with the fluidity of phenotypes found in nature. One such attempt at solving this “species problem” is known as Homeostatic Property Cluster theory (HPC), which suggests that species are not defined by singular essences, but by clusters of properties that a species tends to possess. I contend that the arbitrary nature of HPC’s kind criteria would permit a biological brand of functionalism to inform species boundaries, thereby validating synthetic organisms as members of a species that do not belong
creator: Caleb Hazelwood
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2017-04-19
publication date: 2017-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 14
ending page: 23
doi: 10.33043/S.10.1.14-23

In Defense of Strong AI
type: item
description: This paper argues against John Searle in defense of the potential for computers to understand language (“Strong AI”) by showing that semantic meaning is itself a second-order system of rules that connects symbols and syntax with extralinguistic facts. Searle’s Chinese Room Argument is contested on theoretical and practical grounds by identifying two problems in the thought experiment, and evidence about “machine learning” is used to demonstrate that computers are already capable of learning to form true observation sentences in the same way humans do. Finally, sarcasm is used as an example to extend the argument to more complex uses of language
creator: Corey Baron
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2017-04-19
publication date: 2017-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 38
ending page: 49
doi: 10.33043/S.10.1.38-49

Rethinking Philosophy and Race
type: item
description: The Stance team spoke with Charles Mills, noted philosopher and John Evans Professor of Moral and Intellectual Philosophy at Northwestern University whose work focuses on issues of social class, gender, and race, on December 1, 2014. Dr. Mills reviewed Stance’s transcription of the interview and made slight corrections for grammar, style, and reduction of repetition. He also inserted a sentence or two to add clarity. We hope readers find the result illuminating.
creator: Arthur Soto
creator: Charles Mills
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2015-04-18
publication date: 2015-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 81
ending page: 107
doi: 10.33043/S.8.1.81-107

The Intersections between Self-Deception and Inconsistency
type: item
description: The relationship between the concepts of bad faith, coined by Jean-Paul Sartre, and cognitive dissonance, developed by Leon Festinger, is often misunderstood. Frequently, the terms are over-generalized and equivocated as synonymous ideas. This paper attempts to clarify the intricacies of these two concepts, outlining their similarities and differences.
creator: Hannah Bahnmiller
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2015-04-18
publication date: 2015-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 71
ending page: 80
doi: 10.33043/S.8.1.71-80

Multilateral Retributivism
type: item
description: In this paper I argue for a theory of punishment I call Multilateral Retributivism. Typically retributive notions of justice are unilateral: focused on one person’s desert. I argue that our notions of desert are multilateral: multiple people are owed when a moral crime is committed. I argue that the purpose of punishment is communication with the end-goal of reconciling the offender to society. This leads me to conclude that the death penalty and life without parole are unjustified because they necessarily cut communication short.
creator: Richard R. Eva
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2015-04-18
publication date: 2015-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 65
ending page: 70
doi: 10.33043/S.8.1.65-70

Duality Unresolved and Darwinian Dilemmas
type: item
description: By using Sharon Street’s Darwinian Dilemma, Katarzyna de Lazari-Radek and Peter Singer attempt to show that Sidgwick’s duality of practical reason, whereby an agent has equal reason to act in their own interests or act impartially for the benefit of all, is not actually a duality; rather, reasons for action are solely impartial due to the unreliability of intuitions favoring self-interested behavior. I argue that Lazari Radek and Singer fail to accomplish their goal. I argue that Singer has previously provided an account of impartiality that makes it just as unreliable on the same grounds as self-interested tendencies. Sidgwick’s duality remains unresolved.
creator: Anson Tullis
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2015-04-18
publication date: 2015-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 55
ending page: 64
doi: 10.33043/S.8.1.55-64

Concreteness and Contraception
type: item
description: In this paper, I analyze Simone de Beauvoir’s goals for women expressed in The Second Sex and compare these goals to the opportunities created by the Affordable Care Act’s contraceptive mandate. Though the contraceptive mandate advances Beauvoir’s goal of concrete equality by supporting economic independence and recognizing women’s sexual freedom, there are social and political limitations to these advancements.
creator: Katie Lane Kirkland
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2015-04-18
publication date: 2015-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 47
ending page: 53
doi: 10.33043/S.8.1.47-53

Defending a Benefit-Based Approach to Compensation for Necessary Losses
type: item
description: This paper examines cases when compensation follows from necessary actions that cause harm. I posit that we can determine when compensation is due in instances of necessity by referring to the distribution of benefits and losses that result from the action.
creator: Brandon Ferrick
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2015-04-18
publication date: 2015-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 39
ending page: 45
doi: 10.33043/S.8.1.39-45

There Are No Genuine Disagreements about Funniness
type: item
description: I argue that there are no genuine disagreements about whether something is funny. My argument rests largely on the premise that something is funny only if someone experiences it as funny. The bulk of this paper is spent supporting this premise, primarily through an analysis of the meaning of “funniness.” The rest of the paper is spent demonstrating how my conclusion follows from this premise.
creator: Eric Badovinatz
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2015-04-18
publication date: 2015-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 29
ending page: 37
doi: 10.33043/S.8.1.29-37

Nietzsche and the Prince
type: item
description: The main character of Fyodor Dostoyevsky’s novel The Idiot is a devout Orthodox Christian named Prince Myshkin. Friedrich Nietzsche, who is intensely critical of Christianity, and Myshkin share the same views on shame and pity despite their apparent ideological differences. They condemn the damaging effects of shame and praise the redeeming quality of pity for people who are put to shame. Nietzsche and Myshkin criticize the moral aspect of Christianity, but Nietzsche generalizes it for all of Christianity and Myshkin limits it to the Catholic Church. In the end, they both advocate a philosophy of love for humanity.
creator: Ian Ferguson
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2015-04-18
publication date: 2015-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 19
ending page: 27
doi: 10.33043/S.8.1.19-27

The Contemporary American Child as a Docile Consumptive Body
type: item
description: In this paper, I argue that the contemporary relationship between children and advertising can be seen as illustrative of Foucault’s theory of disciplinary power and docile body production. I contend that, within the context of a consumption-based economy, an individual’s prime utility is her rate of personal consumption. Therefore, the subjection of children to ubiquitous advertising can be seen as the discipline through which the utility of personal consumption is maximized.
creator: Camilla Cannon
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2015-04-18
publication date: 2015-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 9
ending page: 18
doi: 10.33043/S.8.1.9-18

Bodies of Philosophy
type: item
description: Article published in Stance by Wolfe and Grosz
creator: Esther Wolfe
creator: Elizabeth Grosz
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2014-04-18
publication date: 2014-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 115
ending page: 126
doi: 10.33043/S.7.1.115-126

Ideological Domination: Deconstructing the Paradox of the American Dream and the Working Class Promise
type: item
description: The “American Dream” and “Working Class Promise” ideologies are ubiquitously dispersed in American society. These ideologies posit values of equality and opportunity. In this paper, I deconstruct these two ideologies in order to examine the effects these ideologies have on income inequality, social inequality, and social immobility. I argue these ideologies create a paradox in society whereby the more these ideologies are believed, the more the ideologies exacerbate income inequality, social inequality, and social immobility.
creator: Betty Stoneman
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2014-04-18
publication date: 2014-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 105
ending page: 114
doi: 10.33043/S.7.1.105-114

An Examination of Disgust and Its Relation to Morality
type: item
description: In his book Yuck!: The Nature and Moral Significance of Disgust, Daniel Kelly synthesizes a growing body of research on disgust and briefly explores the philosophical role of the emotion. This paper presents arguments for the position that disgust should not be considered a source of moral knowledge, a position that Kelly suggests but fails to illustrate. The paper also explores implications of this view, specifically concerning the ways we should seek to manipulate our disgust reactions in order to improve moral reasoning.
creator: Jessa Wood
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2014-04-18
publication date: 2014-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 97
ending page: 104
doi: 10.33043/S.7.1.97-104

Feminist Critique of Joseph Stiglitz’s Approach to the Problems of Global Capitalism
type: item
description: In his book Making Globalization Work, Joseph Stiglitz proposes reforms to address problems arising from the global spread of capitalism, problems that he asserts are not inherent to globalization or capitalism but are due to the way those systems have been “managed.” Conversely, postcolonial feminist theorist Chanda Talpade Mohanty’s analysis of those same systems demonstrates that capitalism is not compatible with global justice. In this essay I use Mohanty’s analysis to argue that Stiglitz’s proposed reforms would not achieve his stated goals and that the global capitalist system must be dismantled if global justice is to be achieved.
creator: Jenna Blake
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2014-04-18
publication date: 2014-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 89
ending page: 96
doi: 10.33043/S.7.1.89-96

The Insubstantial and Exclusionary Nature of Plato’s Aesthetic Theory
type: item
description: In this paper, I argue that Plato’s conversance with art is insubstantial and exclusionary. Art warrants not only subjects in virtue of utility, morality, and pleasure, but also subjects in virtue of feeling, impression, spirituality, and art itself. I will begin by providing Plato’s view and then provide my threefold objection, utilizing examples from art history and the history of aesthetic theory.
creator: Nicholas James Alcock
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2014-04-18
publication date: 2014-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 79
ending page: 88
doi: 10.33043/S.7.1.79-88

An Existentialist Critique of Punishment
type: item
description: In this paper, I provide an account of the way in which practices of punitive justice in the United States permanently foreclose the possibility of an open future for the punished. I argue that participation in a system where those forms of punishment are utilized is an act of bad faith because it involves the denial of the existential freedom of others as well as our own. Using Hannah Arendt’s account of Adolf Eichmann I show how such acts of bad faith are both natural modes of thought as well as inherently dangerous. Finally, I demonstrate that existentialism provides us with the ability to recreate our relationship to others and resist acts of bad faith, especially when it comes to crime and punishment.
creator: Nicholas Logan
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2014-04-18
publication date: 2014-04-18
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 69
ending page: 77
doi: 10.33043/S.7.1.69-77

Philosophy Comes Our of Lives
type: item
description: Marilyn Frye is a noted philosopher and feminist theorist whose works include The Politics of Reality: Essays in Feminist Theory and Willful Virgin: Essays in Feminism as well as various other essays and articles. Frye recently retired from teaching philosophy at Michigan State University. On February 26, 2013, the Stance staff met with Marilyn Frye to talk about her work, her life, and the status of women in the field of philosophy
creator: Marilyn Frye
creator: Ashli Godfrey
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2013-09-17
publication date: 2013-09-17
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 87
ending page: 95
doi: 10.33043/S.6.1.87-95

Not So Innocent
type: item
description: Leibniz seeks to establish the tenability of faith and reason in his moral philosophy through a tripod of thought, consisting of 1) fundamental human goodness; 2) human error in judgment; and 3) that God is just. A difficulty arises concerning how God can justly punish human beings if they always will what is Good. By considering akrasia, which occurs when error is committed despite its clear nonconformity with the Good, and examining the Leibnizian concept of “judgment,” Leibniz’s tripod can be upheld.
creator: Oda Storbråten Davanger
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2013-09-17
publication date: 2013-09-17
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 79
ending page: 86
doi: 10.33043/S.6.1.79-86

Carruthers and Constitutive Self-Knowledge
type: item
description: In his recent book, The Opacity of Mind, Peter Carruthers advances a skeptical theory of self-knowledge, integrating results from experimental psychology and cognitive science.1 In this essay, I want to suggest that the situation is not quite as dire as Carruthers makes it out to be. I respond to Carruthers by advancing a constitutive theory of self-knowledge. I argue that self-knowledge, so understood, is not only compatible with the empirical research that Carruthers utilizes, but also helps to make sense of these results.
creator: John C. Hill
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2013-09-17
publication date: 2013-09-17
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 71
ending page: 78
doi: 10.33043/S.6.1.71-78

Climate Ethics
type: item
description: Anthropogenic climate change (ACC) has been described as a tragedy of the commons (T of C) by Baylor Johnson. Johnson argues that solutions to T of C scenarios reside in collective action rather than individual action, and that our moral obligation is to advocate for collective solutions to ACC. Marion Hourdequin argues that individual action can serve to promote collective action and in doing so it can also serve as an ethical obligation. I contend that individual action holds intrinsic value in lieu of its ability to counteract our susceptibility to the kind of moral corruption espoused by Stephen Gardiner.
creator: Vesak Chi
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2013-09-17
publication date: 2013-09-17
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 63
ending page: 70
doi: 10.33043/S.6.1.63-70

Nietzsche’s Society
type: item
description: This essay asserts that Nietzsche proposes an important role for society within his ethics, and that this societal aspect has been greatly overlooked by Nietzsche scholars. By identifying a soul-state analogy and resemblance to virtue ethics, this essay contends that Nietzsche intends for societies and individuals to be seen as complementary parts of the will to power. Like Aristotle, Nietzsche prescribes an ideal society essential to greatness. By recognizing the importance of the role of society in Nietzsche’s philosophy, Nietzsche scholarship is better positioned to consider new applications of his philosophical principles with his goals in mind.
creator: Kristen Wells
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2013-09-17
publication date: 2013-09-17
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 53
ending page: 62
doi: 10.33043/S.6.1.53-62

Instrumentalism and Poetic Thinking
type: item
description: This paper offers a critique of the instrumental logic of thought found in the middle period of Dewey’s philosophy. His instrumentalism requires that thought serves to effect a physical alteration in the conditions of experience through an experimental act, the results of which retrospectively determine the legitimacy of thought. But missing from his account, I argue, is an explanation of the significant alteration of experience brought about by more aesthetic forms of philosophical thinking, which do not aim to effect any kind of physical alteration. I therefore propose that “poetic thinking” be invoked as a necessary supplement to instrumental thinking.
creator: Mark McGinn
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2013-09-17
publication date: 2013-09-17
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 45
ending page: 52
doi: 10.33043/S.6.1.45-52

Indiscernibles and Plato’s Forms vs. Parmenides
type: item
description: In Parmenides, the young Socrates defends several candidate forms against Parmenides, who makes five objections: the objection of forms of common things, the question of the part vs. the whole, the third man argument, infinite regress, and the greatest difficulty problem. I define forms in terms of Leibniz’s Principle of the Identity of Indiscernibles (PII) in an attempt to overcome Parmenides’ opposition. I show that the main force in Parmenides’ objections consists of absurdities that emerge in relations between forms and particulars: absurdities that are avoided if the form and its instantiation in the particular are identical.
creator: Jenny Carmichael
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2013-09-17
publication date: 2013-09-17
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 37
ending page: 44
doi: 10.33043/S.6.1.37-44

Fatalism and Truth at a Time
type: item
description: In this paper, I will examine an argument for fatalism. I will offer a formalized version of the argument and analyze one of the argument’s most controversial assumptions. Then, I will argue that one ought to reject the assumption that propositions about the future are true facts of the past, even if no one makes reference to such propositions.
creator: Chad Marxen
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2013-09-17
publication date: 2013-09-17
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 29
ending page: 36
doi: 10.33043/S.6.1.29-36

Change and Moral Development in Kant’s Ethics
type: item
description: This paper is concerned with an ambiguous aspect of Kant’s ethics, namely, how moral change is possible. Kant conceives that change is possible, indeed desirable, without making clear the mechanism by which this change occurs. I conclude that one’s moral development must come about through the autonomous rationality of humanity. This allows for the moral law to be held at all times and for the rejection of immoral sentiments and inclinations. Further, it is constant soulsearching that allows one to keep a check on their maxims, facilitating the development of a moral disposition.
creator: Kyle Curran
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2013-09-17
publication date: 2013-09-17
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 21
ending page: 28
doi: 10.33043/S.6.1.21-28

Revising the Principle of Alternate Possibilities
type: item
description: This paper examines the position in moral philosophy that Harry Frankfurt calls the Principle of Alternate Possibilities (PAP). The paper first describes the principle as articulated by A.J. Ayer. Subsequently, the paper examines Frankfurt’s critique and proposed revision of the principle and argues that Frankfurt’s proposal relies on an excessively simplistic account of practical reasoning, which fails to account for the possibility of moral dilemmas. In response, the paper offers a further revision of PAP, which accounts for Frankfurt’s critique, moral dilemmas, and the challenge of causal determinism.
creator: Max Siegel
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2013-09-17
publication date: 2013-09-17
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 15
ending page: 20
doi: 10.33043/S.6.1.15-20

Sexual Harassment and Objectivity
type: item
description: Sexual harassment is often understood as a subjective notion that asks the woman if she has been victimized. This paper argues that we need not ask women if they are victims by conceptualizing sexual harassment as an objective notion that holds the perpetrator accountable for his actions. In making my case, I will apply an objective conception of sexual harassment to the U.S. Supreme Court case Meritor Savings Bank v. Vinson by drawing on the feminist view of sexual harassment given by Anita Superson and the role of equality and autonomy as motivated by Ronald Dworkin and James Griffin, respectively.
creator: Jenna Tomasello
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2013-09-17
publication date: 2013-09-17
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 7
ending page: 14
doi: 10.33043/S.6.1.7-14

Elegy to Narcissus
type: item
description: This poem is a musing on the thought of Heraclitus. The central opposition I reflect from Heraclitus’ fragments is sleep and wakefulness. This opposition is encountered throughout the fragments as the opposition between life and death, vision and darkness, and wisdom and ignorance.
creator: Peter Antich
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-12
publication date: 2019-09-12
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 111
ending page: 114
doi: 10.33043/S.5.1.111-114

Finite in Infinity
type: item
description: One of the main themes in Spinoza’s Ethics is the issue of human freedom: What does it consist in and how may it be attained? Spinoza’s ethical views crucially depend on his metaphysical theory, and this close connection provides the answer to several central questions concerning Spinoza’s conception of human freedom. Firstly, how can we accommodate human freedom within Spinoza’s necessitarianism—in the context of which Spinoza rejects the notion of a free will? Secondly, how can humans, as merely finite beings, genuinely attain freedom? Can Spinoza defend his claim that we may even attain blessedness? I will argue that these questions are answered by appeal to a twofold in human nature. According to Spinoza, we are finite in infinity.
creator: Hannah Laurens
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2012-09-12
publication date: 2012-09-12
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 97
ending page: 109
doi: 10.33043/S.5.1.97-109

To Gay, or Not To Gay
type: item
description: This work examines the structure of discourses on homosexuality, taking the nature-versus-nurture question as a case study, in order to display the incoherency that results from taking such questions for granted. This paper critically explores the alleged neutrality and objectivity of discourses on sexuality, and within this exploration, a breakdown of the categories of sexuality, sex, gender, and nature occurs. What is shown is that the breakdown of these categories renders the nature-versus-nurture Question itself quite questionable
creator: Debra Bellamy
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2012-09-12
publication date: 2012-09-12
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 85
ending page: 96
doi: 10.33043/S.5.1.85-96

The Truth of the Matter
type: item
description: With the rise of state sponsored standardized testing and curriculum alignment, it is important to consider the impact such practices may have on educational aims. In this paper, I argue that critical thinking ought to be the principle aim in every educational pursuit, and that practices such as “teaching to the test” may be detrimental to its development. I maintain these claims with a discussion of the philosophical works of Harvey Siegel, Israel Scheffler, and John Dewey. Operating from their definitions of critical thinking, rationality, and education respectively, I offer support for my conclusion based on one’s ability to challenge the soundness of claims, and the revisional quality of true belief. The issue of critical thinking as general or subject specific is also addressed. Using Siegel’s notion of a critical spirit, I propose that a universal quality of critical thinking lies in its normative as opposed to technical aspects.
creator: Vincent Sawaya
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2012-09-12
publication date: 2012-09-12
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 75
ending page: 84
doi: 10.33043/S.5.1.75-84

The Principle of Implicit Ignorance
type: item
description: The following is a foundationalist exercise based upon a single observation or postulate distinguishing one’s knowledge of information versus one’s knowledge of one’s former unknowing of that information. This postulate is titled the “principle of implicit ignorance.” Utilizing this postulate, several theorems are constructed including the equivalence to Hume’s thesis regarding the absence of knowledge of a necessary connection. The postulate is then negated, demonstrating equivalence to Kant’s thesis regarding the presence of synthetic a priori statements. The final result is a single general epistemic postulate that brokers between the two respective positions. Because both systems are the result of this general principle, rejecting the results of one system necessarily forces one into the contrary position.
creator: Phillip Curtsmith
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2012-09-12
publication date: 2012-09-12
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 63
ending page: 73
doi: 10.33043/S.5.1.63-73

Understanding Thomas Reid
type: item
description: Thomas Reid offers a powerful challenge to Hume and his skeptical system. In “Thomas Reid on Epistemic Principles,” William Alston gives an explanation of that challenge and concludes in favor of a Reidian-inspired thesis. I argue, however, that Alston’s thesis is a diluted version of Reid’s radical position, one that Reid’s principles cannot accommodate. Thus, I conclude that, because Alston’s position is not available, we are left with Reid’s radical thesis, with which we are rightly uncomfortable.
creator: Garrett Allen
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2012-09-12
publication date: 2012-09-12
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 55
ending page: 62
doi: 10.33043/S.5.1.55-62

Kept Down By the Man, Damn the Man
type: item
description: While Feminism and Marxism each promote revolution in the name of equality, Feminist struggle is dismissed by Marxism. As workers, women face the capitalist narrative, but women’s alienation is deeper than mere Marxist alienation. Women face the additional narrative of the patriarchy. This paper seeks to show that true Marxist revolution is impossible unless it is preceded by a Feminist revolution that breaks gender and sexual stigmas.
creator: Amanda Frankel
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2012-09-12
publication date: 2012-09-12
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 45
ending page: 54
doi: 10.33043/S.5.1.45-54

Descriptions of Scientific Revolutions
type: item
description: The twentieth century saw extended development in the philosophy of science to incorporate contemporary expansions of scientific theory and investigation. Richard Rorty was a prominent and rather controversial thinker who maintained that all progress, from social change to scientific inquiry, was achieved through the redescription of existing vocabularies. However, this theory fails to describe revolutionary scientific progress. Thomas Kuhn’s theories of paradigm change, as first described in his seminal work The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, better portray this process. I attempt to show this by applying Kuhn’s and Rorty’s views to examples of scientific progress and comparing the results.
creator: Kyle Cavagnini
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2012-09-12
publication date: 2012-09-12
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 31
ending page: 43
doi: 10.33043/S.5.1.31-43

Science
type: item
description: Thomas Kuhn argues that scientific advancements sometimes involve paradigm shifts between incommunsurable theories, thoughts, and concepts. I argue that the phenomenon Kuhn is attempting to describe is better explained as akin to a greatest integer function of punctuated equilibrium. I conclude that Kuhn is mistaken in thinking that science is an actively vigorous, cumulative discipline.
creator: Kristianne C. Anor
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2012-09-12
publication date: 2012-09-12
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 19
ending page: 30
doi: 10.33043/S.5.1.19-30

Across and Beyond
type: item
description: This paper examines two senses of the term “transgender:” transgender as across the gender binary and transgender as beyond the gender binary. Explored are the difficulties this ambiguity poses to transpeople. In short, using the theories of Ferdinand de Saussure and Richard Rorty, this paper argues that the meaning of “transgender” must simultaneously embrace both senses of the term, rather than one or the other.
creator: Gunnar Lund
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2012-09-12
publication date: 2012-09-12
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 7
ending page: 18
doi: 10.33043/S.5.1.7-18

Book Review
type: item
description: Article published in Stance by Brittney Sovik
creator: Brittney Sovik
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2011-09-12
publication date: 2011-09-12
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 115
ending page: 118
doi: 10.33043/S.4.1.115-118

The Universe Began to Exist?
type: item
description: William Lane Craig offers two philosophical arguments for the conclusion that the universe began to exist. To be compelling, these arguments must not only be sound—we must also have reasons to believe that they are sound. I determine that these arguments do not provide such reasons to many individuals. The arguments ultimately rely on supposedly intuitively obvious absurdities. However, if one fails to see these ostensible absurdities—as many philosophers do—then for her, Craig’s arguments lack all epistemic force.
creator: Blake McAllister
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2011-09-12
publication date: 2011-09-12
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 103
ending page: 114
doi: 10.33043/S.4.1.103-114

A New Approach to the Paradox of Fiction
type: item
description: It seems that an intuitive characterization of our emotional engagement with fiction contains a paradox, which has been labelled the ‘Paradox of Fiction’. Using insights into the nature of mental content gained from the disjunctive theory of perception I propose a novel solution to the Paradox, explained and motivated by reference to Kendall Walton’s influential account of fictionality. Using this insight I suggest that we can take the phenomenology of fictional engagement seriously in a way not allowed by Walton.
creator: Pete Faulconbridge
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2011-09-12
publication date: 2011-09-12
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 91
ending page: 101
doi: 10.33043/S.4.1.91-101

A Rawlsian Revitalization of Gewirth’s Normative Structure for Action
type: item
description: Alan Gewirth’s Reason and Morality justifies certain fundamental moral principles and develops morality out of the basic structure of action. Contemporary literature exposes a critical flaw in the second stage of Gewirth’s argument contending that Gewirth fails to create agent-neutral moral claims. In order to provide a transfer of interests between agents, the solution to Gewirth’s problem, I argue that certain Rawlsian concepts buttress and are consistent with Gewirth’s argument for the normative structure of action.
creator: Bo Fox Pons
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2011-09-12
publication date: 2011-09-12
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 79
ending page: 89
doi: 10.33043/S.4.1.79-89

Mathematical Infinity and the Presocratic Apeiron
type: item
description: The Presocratic notion of apeiron, often translated as “unbounded,” has been the subject of interest in classical philosophy. Despite apparent similarities between apeiron and infinity, classicists have typically been reluctant to equate the two, citing the mathematically precise nature of infinity. This paper aims to demonstrate that the properties that Anaximander, Zeno, and Anaxagoras attach to apeiron are not fundamentally different from the characteristics that constitute mathematical infinity. Because the sufficient explanatory mathematical tools had not yet been developed, however, their quantitative reasoning remains implicit. Consequentially, the relationship between infinity and apeiron is much closer than classical scholarship commonly suggests.
creator: Austin Heath
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2014-09-11
publication date: 2014-09-11
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 59
ending page: 68
doi: 10.33043/S.7.1.59-68

Gettiering Goldman
type: item
description: This paper examines the causal theory of knowledge put forth by Alvin Goldman in his 1967 paper “A Causal Theory of Knowing.” Goldman contends that a justified, true belief is knowledge if and only if it is causally connected to the fact that makes it true. This paper provides examples, however, of justified, true beliefs with such causal connections that are clearly not knowledge. The paper further shows that attempts to salvage the causal theory are unsatisfactory.
creator: Kenneth Stalkfleet
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-11
publication date: 2019-09-11
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 69
ending page: 78
doi: 10.33043/S.4.1.69-78

A Critical Assessment of George Klosko’s Version of the Principle of Fair Play
type: item
description: The nature of our obligation to obey the law has consistently been an important object of philosophical dispute. Fair play based theories of obligation purport to show that it is unfair for us to benefit from an organizational scheme (such as the state) without contributing our fair share to the provision of goods. George Klosko is a major proponent of this approach. I develop his particular version of the argument from fair play into a defensible theory of citizens’ obligation to obey the laws of their state.
creator: Leonardo Moauro
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-11
publication date: 2019-09-11
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 61
ending page: 68
doi: 10.33043/S.4.1.61-68

A Multi-Causal Approach To Synchronicity
type: item
description: Synchronicity has long been described as an ‘acausal’ connecting principle. However, the use of this descriptor is not only misleading, but also outright false on any seriously considered picture of synchronicity due to admissions of multiple types of causes. Furthermore, previous attempts to clarify the ‘acausal’ label have served only to further muddy the waters of discussion. A ‘multi-causal’ conception of synchronicity is proposed to ease and encourage future discussion in many disciplines.
creator: Zachary Stinson
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-11
publication date: 2019-09-11
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 49
ending page: 59
doi: 10.33043/S.4.1.49-59

Ruminations on Intermittent Existence
type: item
description: Can objects exist, cease to exist, and then exist once more? I lay out three ways to think about intermittent existence (IE). The first section is based on intuitions. The second section will show that the intuitions are bolstered by the concept of supervenience. The final section will argue that the strongest way to think about IE, and about supervenience, is in terms of mereology, the theory of parts and wholes.
creator: Anthony Adrian
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-11
publication date: 2019-09-11
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 39
ending page: 48
doi: 10.33043/S.4.1.39-48

How We Are Moral
type: item
description: In this paper, I reconstruct Hobbes’ theory of self-love. I then examine Hume’s arguments that (i) self-love does not properly account for moral behavior and (ii) self-love is unnecessary for moral theory. I argue that Hobbesian self-love can account for both of Hume’s objections. Further, I use an analysis of Hobbes’ Deliberation to show, contra Hume, that self-love does not entail a lack of intention in moral action.
creator: Jenna Kreyche
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-11
publication date: 2019-09-11
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 27
ending page: 38
doi: 10.33043/S.4.1.27-38

The Productive Citizen
type: item
description: This paper argues for analyzing the systematic invisibility of persons living with disabilities by temporalizing their oppression within a framework of “productive time,” which I posit as a normative sense of time by which cultural products and practices appear within capitalist economies. I argue that productive time is employed in cultural evaluations of actions that render persons with disabilities as “non-productive agents” who cannot partake in historical processes. My hope is that a theory of productive time will assist social justice efforts in analyzing the oppression of particular minority groups by identifying and combating harmful social values.
creator: Lauren Pass
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-11
publication date: 2019-09-11
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 51
ending page: 58
doi: 10.33043/S.7.1.51-58

Resolving the Paradox of Fiction
type: item
description: In this paper, I examine the Paradox of Fiction: (1) in order for us to have genuine and rational emotional responses to a character or situation, we must believe that the character or situation is not purely fictional, (2) we believe that fictional characters and situations are purely fictional, and (3) we have genuine and rational emotional responses to fictional characters and situations. After defending (1) and (2) against formidable objections and considering the plausibility of ~(3) in isolation of (1) and (2), I conclude that we should resolve the Paradox of Fiction by rejecting (3).
creator: Anna Brinkerhoff
rights: Copyright (c) 0
date: 2019-09-11
publication date: 2019-09-11
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 41
ending page: 50
doi: 10.33043/S.7.1.41-50

Rusbridger’s “The Snowden Leaks and the Public” and Mill’s Utilitarianism
type: item
description: Abstract: In the wake of the controversial Snowden leaks, Alan Rusbridger observes that the National Security Administration [NSA] and Government Communications Headquarters [GCHQ] maintain that their mass spying is justified because it prevents the world from “going dark.” This paper will explore the meaning and philosophical significance of “going dark” and argue that the NSA and GCHQ’s claim appeals—wittingly or unwittingly—to J.S. Mill’s ethical principle of utility. This paper will therefore critique this argument within Mill’s utilitarian framework to demonstrate that its appeal to utility is illegitimate. Finally, this paper will argue that utility dictates that this mass surveillance is unjustifiable and should be terminated.
creator: Casey Hladik
rights: Copyright (c) 2014 Casey Hladik https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-11
publication date: 2019-09-11
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 29
ending page: 40
doi: 10.33043/S.7.1.29-40

A Defense of Form
type: item
description: By applying the normative basis of Confucian ritual activity to the repeatable designs of internet memes, this essay explores the ways in which socially recognized forms can allow individuals to engage in thoughtful activity with what is represented by but cannot be reduced to form: the particulars of human experience. The goal of this insight is to suggest that the value of art and ideas cannot be isolated from how individuals interact with them, and thus critique should examine how well an idea or piece promotes an active, creative, and critical relationship to a person’s own experiences.
creator: Nicholas Brown
rights: Copyright (c) 0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-10
publication date: 2019-09-10
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 19
ending page: 27
doi: 10.33043/S.7.1.19-27

Beliefs and Blameworthiness
type: item
description: In this paper, I analyze epistemic blameworthiness. After presenting Michael Bergmann’s definition of epistemic blameworthiness, I argue that his definition is problematic because it does not have a control condition. I conclude by offering an improved definition of epistemic blameworthiness and defending this definition against potential counterexamples.
creator: Liz Jackson
rights: Copyright (c) 2014 Liz Jackson https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-10
publication date: 2019-09-10
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 7
ending page: 17
doi: 10.33043/S.7.1.7-17

Certainly Uncertain
type: item
description: In this paper, I contrast pre- and post-Socratic Greek thought, particularly with respect to Apollonian optimism and Dionysian pessimism. I show how Socrates’ judgment of a “right” way of living undermined Greek pessimism and was the first step towards modern scientific optimism, the belief that the world can be understood. I then argue that new developments in quantum physics make this optimism untenable, and I finally assert that Nietzschean pessimism is a coherent and beneficial metaphysical perspective.
creator: Stephen Bailey
rights: Copyright (c) 2011 Bailey https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-10
publication date: 2019-09-10
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 15
ending page: 26
doi: 10.33043/S.4.1.15-26

The Piety of Escape
type: item
description: This paper examines two seemingly contradictory views of piety found in Plato’s Euthyphro and Crito. Using the Socratic dialogues for evidence of what Socrates actually believed and to piece together a Socratic account of piety, it seems that his argument in favor of remaining in prison is inconsistent with his own beliefs. The paper concludes that Socrates ought not to have thought it was impious to escape from prison.
creator: Phillip Shannon
rights: Copyright (c) 2011 Shannon https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-10
publication date: 2019-09-10
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 3
ending page: 14
doi: 10.33043/S.4.1.3-14

If Nietzsche Only Knew
type: item
description: This paper compares Buddhism with the philosophies of Friedrich Nietzsche and speculates how he would have reacted to Buddhism if he had understood it more accurately. I will focus the discussion on two central philosophies of Buddhism, which Nietzsche misinterpreted: Nirvana and suffering. It will be shown through an examination of selected writings and key philosophies of Nietzsche that if he had a better understanding of Nirvana and suffering then he would have been significantly more favorable towards Buddhism and would have found it to have close similarities to his own beliefs.
creator: Jared Lincourt
rights: Copyright (c) 2010 Lincourt https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-10
publication date: 2019-09-10
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 62
ending page: 68
doi: 10.33043/S.3.1.62-68

A Substantive Revision to Firth's Ideal Observer Theory
type: item
description: This paper examines Ideal Observer Theory and uses criticisms of it to lay the foundation for a revised theory first suggested by Jonathan Harrison called Ideal Moral Reaction Theory. Harrison’s Ideal Moral Reaction Theory stipulates that the being producing an ideal moral reaction be dispassionate. This paper argues for the opposite: an Ideal Moral Reaction must be performed by a passionate being because it provides motivation for action and places ethical decision-making within human grasp.
creator: Nancy Rankin
rights: Copyright (c) 2010 Rankin https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-10
publication date: 2019-09-10
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 55
ending page: 61
doi: 10.33043/S.3.1.55-61

The Skeptic's Language Game
type: item
description: This paper seeks to critique Pyrrhonean skepticism by way of language analysis. Linguistic aspects of Pyrrhonism are first examined utilizing the later writing of Wittgenstein. Pyrrhonean languageuse is then critiqued using H.P. Grice’s concept of implicature to demonstrate shared knowledge between speakers. Finally, a teleological model of communication is sketched using ideas from Jerry Fodor. If the Pyrrhonist denies speaking to communicate mental states, we are justified in questioning why we should listen to what she says.
creator: Kyle Shaffer
rights: Copyright (c) 2010 Shaffer https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-10
publication date: 2019-09-10
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 47
ending page: 54
doi: 10.33043/S.3.1.47-54

Relational Obligations
type: item
description: This paper attempts to demonstrate that special responsibilities exist as a necessary and fundamental component of relationships. It seeks to show that, while special responsibilities may be superseded by other relevant concerns, they remain absolute. The paper attempts to demonstrate further that, even in cases of repugnant conclusion, special responsibilities exhibit a residual nature. It argues that such obligations are not always voluntary entered, but nevertheless represent prima facie duties to those parties involved.
creator: Thomas Jared Farmer
rights: Copyright (c) 2010 Farmer https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-10
publication date: 2019-09-10
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 39
ending page: 46
doi: 10.33043/S.3.1.39-46

The Strength of Relationships
type: item
description: I endeavor to show that Descartes’ attribute-mode distinction cannot be characterized in terms of the determinable-determinate relation. I identify the latter’s formal and modal properties in order to determine whether the former shares them, which ultimately shows distinctness. I then indicate which property accounts for the differences. I conclude that the relation that unites modes under an attribute is weaker than that which groups determinates under some determinable, respectively, the relations of inherence and incompatibility.
creator: Said Saillant
rights: Copyright (c) 2010 Saillant https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-10
publication date: 2019-09-10
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 33
ending page: 38
doi: 10.33043/S.3.1.33-38

Weighing Solutions to the Lottery Puzzle
type: item
description: The lottery puzzle can elicit strong intuitions in favour of skepticism, according to which we ordinary language-users speak falsely about knowledge with shocking regularity. Various contextualist and invariantist responses to the puzzle attempt to avoid this unwelcome result and preserve the competence of ordinary speakers. I will argue that these solutions can be successful only if they respect intuitions of a certain kind, and proceed to judge competing solutions by this criterion.
creator: Mark Bowker
rights: Copyright (c) 2010 Bowker https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-10
publication date: 2019-09-10
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 25
ending page: 32
doi: 10.33043/S.3.1.25-32

Population Control
type: item
description: The planet’s swiftly growing population coupled with the lack of food security and the degradation of natural resources has caused many demographers to worry about the ramifications of unchecked population growth while many philosophers worry about the ethical issues surrounding the methods of population control. Therefore, I intend to argue a system of encouraging a decrease in personal fertility rate via financial incentives offers a solution that is both viable and not morally reprehensible.
creator: Alicia M.R. Donner
rights: Copyright (c) 2010 Donner https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-10
publication date: 2019-09-10
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 17
ending page: 24
doi: 10.33043/S.3.1.17-24

Possibility, Novelty, and Creativity
type: item
description: I am trying to develop an account of possibility that is consistent with the changing world of our experience. Possibility is often viewed as something that has the same form as actuality, minus existence. Or it is taken that what a possibility is, is a (re)combination of the elements of actuality. Neither of these views of possibility can countenance radical novelty. Using Bergson and Whitehead, I begin to construct an account of possibility compatible with genuine novelty.
creator: Alex Haitos
rights: Copyright (c) 2010 Haitos https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-10
publication date: 2019-09-10
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 9
ending page: 16
doi: 10.33043/S.3.1.9-16

The Principle of Sufficient Reason and Free Will
type: item
description: I examine Leibniz’s version of the Principle of Sufficient Reason with respect to free will, paying particular attention to Peter van Inwagen’s argument that this principle leads to determinism. Ultimately I conclude that Leibniz’s formulation is incompatible with free will. I then discuss a reformulation of the Principle of Sufficient Reason endorsed by Alexander Pruss that, I argue, manages to both retain the strength of Leibniz’s formulation and remain consistent with free will.
creator: Blake McAllister
rights: Copyright (c) 2010 McAllister https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-10
publication date: 2019-09-10
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 1
ending page: 8
doi: 10.33043/S.3.1.1-8

A Metaphysics for Mathematical and Structural Realism
type: item
description: The goal of this paper is to preserve realism in both ontology and truth for the philosophy of mathematics and science. It begins by arguing that scientific realism can only be attained given mathematical realism due to the indispensable nature of the latter to the prior. Ultimately, the paper argues for a position combining both Ontic Structural Realism and Ante Rem Structuralism, or what the author refers to as Strong Ontic Structural Realism, which has the potential to reconcile realism for both science and mathematics. The paper goes on to claims that this theory does not succumb to the same traditional epistemological problems, which have damaged the credibility of its predecessors.
creator: Adam InTae Gerard
rights: Copyright (c) 2009 Gerard https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-09
publication date: 2019-09-09
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 75
ending page: 89
doi: 10.33043/S.2.1.75-89

A Doctor and a Scholar
type: item
description: Too often critics ignore the philosophic significance of Eryximachus, the physician from Plato’s Symposium, and mistakenly dismiss Eryximachus’ presence in the text. However, this paper argues that a review of the role of medicine in the Platonic dialogues, coupled with a close reading of the Symposium’s structure and language reveals how the physician’s emphasis on love as a harmonizing force is analogous to Socrates’ emphasis on balance and harmony throughout the dialogues. Also, the description of the good physician is reflective of the way a good philosopher operates. By employing the medical trope, Eryximachus’ speech allows the reader greater insight into Platonic philosophy.
creator: Ronald Ross
rights: Copyright (c) 2009 Ross https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-09
publication date: 2019-09-09
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 67
ending page: 74
doi: 10.33043/S.2.1.67-74

Morality with an Accent
type: item
description: In this paper, the difficulties inherent in the debate between moral nativists and antinativists, who differ in their beliefs on the nature of systems of morality, are shown to exemplify the need for philosophers to support their views with empirical data. Furthermore, it proposes that an empirical study of first-generation immigrant populations has the potential to resolve the debate over moral nativism, as it would allow researchers to observe the moral “critical period.” Based on the recent philosophical advances made through experimental evidence, this paper goes on to argue that empirical data is a valuable source of information from which philosophers ought to draw.
creator: Douglas Romney
rights: Copyright (c) 2009 Romney https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-09
publication date: 2019-09-09
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 61
ending page: 66
doi: 10.33043/S.2.1.61-66

What (Doesn't) Make an Heroic Act?
type: item
description: This paper focuses on the nature of saintly or heroic acts, which, according to J.O. Urmson, exist as a fourth, less traditional category of moral actions. According to this division, heroic acts are those, which have positive moral value, but cannot be demanded of an individual as their duty; however, this paper argues that Urmson is mistaken in his claim that a consequentialist ethical framework is the most capable of accounting for heroic acts. Furthermore, this paper claims that an Aristotelian account is the most appropriate ethical theory to consider, which could better countenance the existence of heroic acts.
creator: Jonathan Payton
rights: Copyright (c) 2009 Payton https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-09
publication date: 2019-09-09
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 57
ending page: 60
doi: 10.33043/S.2.1.57-60

The Ethical Implications of Evolutionary Theory
type: item
description: This essay is primarily concerned with important arguments involved in the debate about the relationship between evolution and morality. Though the paper holds that it is plausible that certain natural traits would have evolved into human moral sentiments, it argues that evolutionary theory cannot tell us how to be good people or why moral sentiments ought to take priority over immoral sentiments. Evolutionary theory is in this way an incomplete moral theory, analyzing how humans and human morality evolved through natural selection can uncover implications of evolutionary theory, which have a strong impact on a theory of morality
creator: Marc Anthony Parker
rights: Copyright (c) 2009 Parker https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-09
publication date: 2019-09-09
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 49
ending page: 56
doi: 10.33043/S.2.1.49-56

A Consistent Consolation
type: item
description: This paper seeks to defend Philosophy’s account of true happiness in Boethius’ Consolation of Philosophy. Although philosopher John Marenbon claims that Philosophy provides Boethius with two conflicting accounts of happiness, this paper argues that she consistently advocates a single account of true happiness. Ultimately, the paper claims that Marenbon is mistaken in his interpretation of Philosophy account of true happiness. What Marenbon interprets as an alternate account of the nature of true happiness is actually a component of Philosophy’s dialectical method and not a separate account.
creator: Allison Glasscock
rights: Copyright (c) 2009 Glsscock https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-09
publication date: 2019-09-09
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 42
ending page: 48
doi: 10.33043/S.2.1.42-48

The Environmental Crises
type: item
description: In the face of an ensuing environmental crisis, this paper suggests that currently accepted modes of environmentalist thought have not been effective enough in enacting positive change. Anthropocentrism provides something that environmental philosophy needs – wide acceptance and public appeal. This paper argues that an environmental ethic that is weakly anthropocentric, in that it finds value in the environment via human values, can be both internally consistent and highly pragmatic. It goes on to examine some pitfalls of Deep Ecological environmental philosophy, which could be avoided if a weakly anthropocentric environmental ethic were adopted now.
creator: Beth Mendenhall
rights: Copyright (c) 2009 Mendenhall https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-09
publication date: 2019-09-09
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 35
ending page: 41
doi: 10.33043/S.2.1.35-41

Rethinking the Binary of Pure Objectivity and Relativistic Chaos
type: item
description: This paper seeks to refute some of the common presuppositions of traditional Western epistemologies, which center on the claim that subjectivity cannot be as truth-yielding as "objectivity." This paper argues that aspects of the subjective can effectively be utilized in a valid epistemology attempting to approach an understanding of the truth of lived human experience—i.e. that subjectivity can in certain circumstances be as truth-yielding as, or even more so than, the epistemic ideal of objectivity. Ultimately, this paper concludes that the objective-subjective epistemic binary is artificial and disadvantageous in that neither pure objectivity nor absolute relativity are possible.
creator: Jason Huber
rights: Copyright (c) 2009 Huber https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-09
publication date: 2019-09-09
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 26
ending page: 34
doi: 10.33043/S.2.1.26-34

Visualizing a Critical Mixed-Race Theory
type: item
description: In this paper, questions regarding the cultural understanding of mixed race are explored, which have the ability to complicate the accepted portrayal of race in society as a black/white binary system. Thus, the acknowledgement of something other than this binary system offers new ways of theorizing about race, particularly concerning the sociopolitical implications of mixed-race designation. This paper argues that the visually mixed-race person has a certain direct ability to challenge the binary and its racist logic. Furthermore, this paper goes on to offer a unique interpretation of where power for working against a racially oppressive system lies within critical mixed-race theory.
creator: Desiree Valentine
rights: Copyright (c) 2009 Valentine https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-09
publication date: 2019-09-09
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 18
ending page: 25
doi: 10.33043/S.2.1.18-25

Generation Lobotomy
type: item
description: This paper primarily explores the ethical debate surrounding the use of memory erasure for therapeutic ends. It argues that procedures such as kinase inhibition therapy, which can entail memory erasure in the individual, incur a high cost in terms of the integrity of our individual identities, thus jeopardizing our claim to individual rights and accountability. Therefore, we should reserve such therapies for the extreme cases in which the procedures have the potential to actually restore a person’s autonomy. Furthermore, this paper goes on to explore which situations might fit this criterion, while still accounting for the cost of memory erasure in each instance.
creator: Amanda Ruiz
rights: Copyright (c) 2009 Ruiz https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-09
publication date: 2019-09-09
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 9
ending page: 17
doi: 10.33043/S.2.1.9-17

The Skeptic's Guide to the Genealogy
type: item
description: This paper seeks to evaluate Nietzsche’s positive ethical vision through a focus on the plausibility of his moral-historical account as it appears in On the Genealogy of Morals. It is then argued that Nietzsche’s account of the “slave revolt in morality” contains shortcomings that necessitate further inquiry into Nietzsche’s consequent ethical vision. Furthermore, the paper goes on to demonstrate that if a proper historical context for the “slave revolt in morality” cannot be identified, or if it cannot be shown that Nietzsche’s ethical vision can stand without such a context, then a neo-Nietzschean ethic must be set aside.
creator: Benjamin Holvey
rights: Copyright (c) 2009 Holvey https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-09
publication date: 2019-09-09
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 1
ending page: 8
doi: 10.33043/S.2.1.1-8

The Politics of Epistemology
type: item
description: This paper focuses on the metaphysical and conceptual structures of reality organization that exist currently in western culture. Taking a feminist perspective, this paper analyzes how some disfavored social groups actively have their identities manipulated and sometimes conceptually erased from the dominant conceptual scheme. Utilizing this analysis, it is concluded that this conceptual scheme perpetuates oppression; therefore, maintained loyalty to it is incompatible with the belief that all people should be treated as full persons.
creator: Cassandra Reed
rights: Copyright (c) 2008 Reed https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-06
publication date: 2019-09-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 50
ending page: 55
doi: 10.33043/S.1.1.50-55

To What Extent is Experience Like Belief?
type: item
description: In this paper, I argue that the connection between experience and belief is far closer than we might first suppose. In defending a broadly representationalist theory of perception, I argue that purportedly irreducible, non-physical entities such as qualia do not pose an intractable problem for physicalist or functionalist accounts of mind.
creator: Sam Hawke
rights: Copyright (c) 2008 Hawke https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-06
publication date: 2019-09-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 44
ending page: 49
doi: 10.33043/S.1.1.44-49

Wittgenstein's Account of Rule-Following and Its Implications
type: item
description: In this paper I present an interpretation of Wittgenstein’s account of rule-following, including what implications he suggests this account has for philosophy. The account suggests that neither one’s interpretation nor the rule itself are criteria by which we may conclude a rule was followed correctly or not. Rather it is through training, regularity, habit and social expectation-in short, by the consequences of action-that an action is considered in accord with a rule. I argue that even if we accept Wittgenstein’s account of rule-following, certain philosophically important implications follow.
creator: Jonathan Langseth
rights: Copyright (c) 2008 Langseth https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-06
publication date: 2019-09-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 38
ending page: 43
doi: 10.33043/S.1.1.38-43

Heidegger and Social Ecology
type: item
description: In this essay I defend Heidegger’s critique of technology against possible criticisms that he may be an anti-humanist and a mystic. This essay will show that Heidegger’s critique of technology is helpful in thinking about ecological questions; and his contributions to such questions is relevant and not radically separated from some of the work of other philosophers today including Karen Warren and Marilyn Frye.
creator: Daniel Cole
rights: Copyright (c) 2008 Cole https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-06
publication date: 2019-09-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 32
ending page: 37
doi: 10.33043/S.1.1.32-37

Motion and Rest from a Chinese Buddhist Perspective
type: item
description: This paper focuses on Seng-Chao’s conception of motion and rest as two different ways to see the same phenomenon and the effect that this has on his understanding of ideas such as impermanence. I point out the parallels that can be made between motion and rest and samsara and nirvana and I argue that a strong Taoist background helps Seng-Chao clarify Indian ideas and make even deeper claims about the true nature of reality.
creator: Caroline Sluyter
rights: Copyright (c) 2008 Sluyter https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-06
publication date: 2019-09-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 26
ending page: 31
doi: 10.33043/S.1.1.26-31

The Foundations of Knowledge in Aristotle and Epicurus
type: item
description: As early proponents of foundationalism, Aristotle and Epicurus share the view that all knowledge rests on indubitable foundations. For Aristotle, these foundations are intellectual first principles. But for Epicurus, sense perception is basic. If certainty is the criterion of knowledge, then, despite their different approaches, neither philosopher succeeds in providing a mechanism sufficient to certify knowledge claims. For the foundationalist wishing to avoid nihilism, therefore, Aristotle’s and Epicurus’ failures are instructive.
creator: Wesley C. Dempster
rights: Copyright (c) 2008 Dempster https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-06
publication date: 2019-09-06
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 20
ending page: 25
doi: 10.33043/S.1.1.20-25

Where Claxton Falls Short
type: item
description: Guy Claxton suggests that post-Industrial Revolution westerners are consumption addicts and argues that we must embrace a more frugal and environmentally considerate lifestyle. However, I argue that Claxton’s analysis and solution to consumption addiction does not penetrate far enough. Through Warren’s ecofeminist reasoning and Heidegger’s notion of technology, I show that the anthropocentric assumption inherent in western consumption engenders a destructive and oppressive worldview by creating the illusion that we are justified in subordinating non-human entities.
creator: Joshua Savage
rights: Copyright (c) 2008 Savage https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-05
publication date: 2019-09-05
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 16
ending page: 19
doi: 10.33043/S.1.1.16-19

Descriptions of God
type: item
description: This paper uses the lessons gathered from a brief consideration of the workings of substantive descriptive phrases to develop two objections to Anselm’s ontological proof of God’s existence. First, one’s understanding of the definition of God does not, as Anselm claims, guarantee that God exists in one’s understanding. Second, the proof depends on a flawed interpretation of the denial of God’s existence. The paper concludes by discussing the broader significance of this second objection.
creator: John Woodlee
rights: Copyright (c) 2008 Woodlee https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-05
publication date: 2019-09-05
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 8
ending page: 15
doi: 10.33043/S.1.1.8-15

A Critical Discussion of Sartre on Love
type: item
description: Pessimism about the stability of intra-personal relationships runs deeply in the philosophy of Jean-Paul Sartre. I begin by examining how this pessimism arises from Sartre’s ontology, particularly considering the attitude of love towards the Other. I then suggest that there may be space within Sartre’s philosophy for a defense of love as a positive relation to the Other which need not be destined to cycle into attitudes toward the Other such as hate or masochism.
creator: Chris Stevens
rights: Copyright (c) 2008 Stevens https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-05
publication date: 2019-09-05
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 2
ending page: 7
doi: 10.33043/S.1.1.2-7

Scientific Minimalism and the Division of Moral Labor in Regulating Dual-Use Research
type: item
description: : In this paper I examine the merits of a “division of moral labor” regulatory system for dual-use research. I borrow an argument from Thomas Douglas against scientific isolationism to show that researchers must be morally responsible for resolving at least some dual-use problems. I then argue that there are key benefits of scientific isolationism that are preserved in a position I call scientific minimalism. I then demonstrate that scientific minimalism, in a division of moral labor system, succeeds in maximizing both scientific freedom and moral efficiency, which I hold to be an essential aim for any proposed alternative regulatory model.
creator: Steven Dykstra
rights: Copyright (c) 2016 Dykstra https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-05
publication date: 2019-09-05
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 33
ending page: 40
doi: 10.33043/S.9.1.33-40

"Hood Politics"
type: item
description: This paper explores the possibility of music to transform the way we understand each other. In particular, it looks at the genre of hip-hop and the ways in which it can serve as a vehicle for understanding black experience. I argue that hip-hop’s structural elements allow artists to convey their living narrative in a way that recognizes, challenges, and changes our conceptual understanding of the black body. Using the works of Darby English and Harry Nethery, I examine hip-hop and apply their arguments to two specific rappers in order to illustrate my argument.
creator: Richard Spradlin
rights: Copyright (c) 2016 Spradlin https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-05
publication date: 2019-09-05
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 41
ending page: 50
doi: 10.33043/S.9.1.41-50

Criminal Justice Without Moral Responsibility
type: item
description: This paper grants the hard determinist position that moral responsibility is not coherent with a deterministic world view and examines hard determinist alternatives to traditional punishment. I claim that hard determinist accounts necessarily involve consequentialist reasoning and discuss problems stemming from them. I also argue that a revised model of traditional consequentialism called complex consequentialism, a view in which multiple values may be considered as ends, provides the best moral framework for a hard determinist account. Ultimately, I examine a criminal justice model that draws heavily on public health ideals and argue that it should considered a complex consequentialist account.
creator: Dane Shade Hannum
rights: Copyright (c) 2016 Hannum https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-05
publication date: 2019-09-05
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 51
ending page: 58
doi: 10.33043/S.9.1.51-58

The Academic Animal is Just an Analogy
type: item
description: The “Spiritual Animal Kingdom” is an often misunderstood section of G.F.W. Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit. Many scholars interpret the ‘Spiritual Animal Kingdom’ as being analogous to intellectual life. While the intellectual life analogy is useful, the restrictive account takes it to be the sole content of this section. In this essay, I argue that the restrictive account misidentifies what Hegel means by die Sache selbst (in English, “the matter in hand”). Such a mistake will affect the ability of consciousness to progress to absolute knowing, the ultimate project for Hegel’s Phenomenology.
creator: Miguel D. Guerrero
rights: Copyright (c) 2016 Guerrero https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-05
publication date: 2019-09-05
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 59
ending page: 66
doi: 10.33043/S.9.1.59-66

Moral Vegetarianism and the Philosophy of Mind
type: item
description: Most arguments for moral vegetarianism rely on the premise that non-human animals can suffer. In this paper I evaluate problems that arise from Peter Carruthers’ Higher-Order Thought theory of consciousness. I argue that, even if we assume that these problems cannot be overcome, it does not follow that we should not subscribe to moral vegetarianism. I conclude that we should act as if non-human animals have subjective experiences for moral reasons, even if we cannot be certain that they do.
creator: C.J. Oswald
rights: Copyright (c) 2016 Oswald https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-05
publication date: 2019-09-05
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 67
ending page: 72
doi: 10.33043/S.9.1.67-72

Purity Balls
type: item
description: In this paper, I draw on the principles of Aristotelian ethics, the work of modern virtue ethicists, and previous feminist critiques of purity balls to interrogate the effects of this practice on moral development. I argue that purity balls discourage young women from making autonomous, informed, and virtuously motivated decisions regarding their sexuality. While most critiques of purity balls are rooted in the explicitly patriarchal structure of these events, my analysis emphasizes the negative impact they have on moral agency. I conclude that purity balls are unethical because of the detrimental effects they have on the becoming of virtuous agents.
creator: Nicole B. Doolen
rights: Copyright (c) 2016 Doolen https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-05
publication date: 2019-09-05
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 73
ending page: 83
doi: 10.33043/S.9.1.73-83

Feminism, Speaking for Others, and the Role of the Philosopher
type: item
description: Article published in Stance by Linda Martin Alcoff
creator: Linda Martin Alcoff
rights: Copyright (c) 2016 Linda Martin Alcoff https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
date: 2019-09-05
publication date: 2019-09-05
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 85
ending page: 105
doi: 10.33043/S.9.1.85-105

If “Everyone Does It,” Then You Can Too
type: item
description: I argue that the “But Everyone Does That” (BEDT) defense can have significant exculpatory force in a legal sense, but not a moral sense. I consider whether legal realism is a better theory of the law than the more orthodox view of respecting the law as it is written. I next examine what the purpose of the law is, especially attending to how widespread disobedience is treated. Finally, I attempt to fit BEDT within Paul Robinson’s framework for categorizing defenses. I conclude that, first, BEDT can have significant exculpatory force; second, a BEDT plea does not comport with either Robinson’s definition of an excuse or other commonly held conceptions and so needs its own classification; and finally, BEDT does not exonerate the offender in a moral sense—only in a legal context.
creator: Charlie Melman
rights: Copyright (c) 2016 Charlie Melman
date: 2018-04-19
publication date: 2018-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 27
ending page: 31
doi: 10.33043/S.9..27-31

Just Visiting: A Working Concept of “Wilderness” for Environmental Ethics and Ordinary Language
type: item
description: This paper argues for retaining the concept of “wilderness” as a significant ethical category and considers arguments by J. Baird Callicott and William Cronon for abandoning it. Counters by Paul M. Keeling and Scott Friskics are evaluated and defended. Lastly, the paper recommends thinking of the term “wilderness” as belonging to a certain range of meanings on a spectrum of naturalness.
creator: Raquel Robles
rights: Copyright (c) 2016 Raquel Robles
date: 2018-04-19
publication date: 2018-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 17
ending page: 25
doi: 10.33043/S.9..17-25

Does The Dao Support Individual Autonomy And Human Rights?
type: item
description: The Universal Declaration of Human Rights lists what have come to be called “first” and “second” generation rights. First generation rights are civil and political; second generation rights are social, economic, and cultural. Western and Asian nations are in disagreement about whether each of these rights is universal. While Western nations strongly believe that first generation rights should be universal, many “Confucian” nations insist that second generation rights precede first generation rights. After analyzing the Confucian values in detail, I conclude that Confucianism supports both generations of rights.
creator: Caroline Carr
rights: Copyright (c) 2016 Caroline Carr
date: 2018-04-19
publication date: 2018-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 9
ending page: 16
doi: 10.33043/S.9..9-16

Front Matter
type: item
description: Table of contents and 2016 staff
creator: Stance Staff
rights: Copyright (c)
date: 2018-04-19
publication date: 2018-04-19
volume: 18
number: 1
starting page: 1
ending page: 7
doi: 10.33043/S.9..1-7